<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	>

<channel>
	<title>English &#8211; Florian Malzacher</title>
	<atom:link href="https://florianmalzacher.de/sprache/english/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>https://florianmalzacher.de</link>
	<description></description>
	<lastBuildDate>Mon, 23 Dec 2024 15:30:20 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<language>de</language>
	<sy:updatePeriod>
	hourly	</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>
	1	</sy:updateFrequency>
	<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4</generator>

 
	<item>
		<title>Zorka Wollny. Choirs with Consequences</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/zorka-wollny-choirs-with-consequences/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 23 Dec 2024 15:26:15 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/zorka-wollny-choirs-with-consequences/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[This could be one way to write a history of recent performing arts: By following artists’ attempts to speak on stage, in staged situations, at all. By Tracing the trials and errors of finding a spoken language that is not pretending to be intrinsically motivated, not presumptuous, not fake. New York’s legendary Wooster Group hiding [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This could be one way to write a history of recent performing arts: By following artists’ attempts to speak on stage, in staged situations, at all. By Tracing the trials and errors of finding a spoken language that is not pretending to be intrinsically motivated, not presumptuous, not fake.</p>
<p>New York’s legendary Wooster Group hiding behind stunning playback virtuosity. The almost-as-legendary British theatre company Forced Entertainment not daring to say word live on stage for almost a decade, only using pre-recorded soundtracks until they came up with the idea of reciting lists and using Q&amp;A games: functional speech instead of feigned psychology. Theatre maker René Pollesch being inspired by the mono-emotional rapid speech of the director and writer John Jesurun. The She She Pop collective rehearsing the quotidian sound of amateurish authenticity that later became mainstream in Reality TV. Rimini Protokoll sending &#8222;real people&#8220; onto the stage instead of performers. How can one stand in front of an audience and speak without falling into the trap of false representation?</p>
<p>For some years, Zorka Wollny also kept tiptoeing around this problem. When there was voice on stage, there were no bodies. When there were bodies, there was no voice. Silent dancers in galleries; invisible sources of sound. Once they finally appeared together in one space, they still were separated: Some bodies moving, others singing.</p>
<p>It was the form of the choir that finally offered a solution. A solution that had aesthetic and ethical reasons and consequences.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">* * * * * * * *</p>
<p>Tunisia, Egypt, Spain, Portugal, Greece. A little later New York, London, Tel Aviv, and Istanbul, then Brazil, Japan, Korea, Argentina . . . the year 2010 kicked off a decade of demonstrations all around the world. The catalysts igniting each instance of unrest may differ, but artists were and are almost always among the first to take up the call for social justice and strengthened democracy. No matter the site (squares and parks like Tahrir, Zuccotti, Syntagma, Taksim, and Maidan), no matter the backdrop (Tokyo after Fukushima, Niemeyer’s iconic parliamentary architecture in Brasilia, or beneath umbrellas in Hong Kong), the same question arose: how could art – how could artistic strategies and tactics – play a relevant role in these movements? A renewed interest in the concepts of gathering and creating public spheres in which society not only is mirrored but constantly tried out, performed, tested, reimagined, or even reinvented, fundamentally changed the artistic discourse.</p>
<p>And so it is neither by chance, nor without larger context. that Wollny’s trajectory of bringing bodies and voices together began around the same time. <em>Oratorio for Orchestra and Warsaw Citizens’ Choir</em> (2011) mixed professional musicians with activists and engaged citizens, translating the genre of the oratorio into a secularized “form of expression for pluralist society, a polyphony of opinions and postulates”. From improvisations and numerous conversations, a libretto of political demands emerged. Behind <em>Oratorio</em> stood the deliberate choice to move orchestra and choir out of the safe space of the concert hall and onto the streets of Warsaw.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Befreiungstheologie</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/befreiungstheologie/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 14 Jun 2024 15:31:52 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/befreiungstheologie/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Im Foyer des Mecklenburgischen Staatstheaters nehmen ziemlich nonnig aussehende Nonnen unbürokratisch Beichten entgegen, stehen aber auch für Selfies zur Verfügung. Die Stimmung ist relaxed, unter das Schweriner Premieren-Abo mischen sich nicht wenige Berliner*innen, Presse, eine Handvoll internationaler Kurator*innen. Das Bizzeln eines möglichen Skandals liegt im Raum. Denn auch wenn Paul Hindemiths über hundert Jahre alte [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Im Foyer des Mecklenburgischen Staatstheaters nehmen ziemlich nonnig aussehende Nonnen unbürokratisch Beichten entgegen, stehen aber auch für Selfies zur Verfügung. Die Stimmung ist relaxed, unter das Schweriner Premieren-Abo mischen sich nicht wenige Berliner*innen, Presse, eine Handvoll internationaler Kurator*innen. Das Bizzeln eines möglichen Skandals liegt im Raum. Denn auch wenn Paul Hindemiths über hundert Jahre alte titelgebende Kurz-Oper <em>Sancta Susana</em> längst kein Aufreger mehr sein mag, als Steilvorlage für Florentina Holzinger – mit ihren lustvoll radikal queer-feministischen Choreografien derzeit unangefochtener shooting star der europäischen Theaterszene – taugt sie allemal. Schließlich geht es um das sexuelle Begehren einer Nonne inklusive angedeutetem Geschlechtsakt mit dem Heiland.</p>
<p>Und tatsächlich beginnt der Abend unter der musikalischen Leitung von Marit Strindlund mehr oder minder werktreu mit der kaum mehr als zwanzig Minuten langen, expressionistisch geprägten Oper: Klosternonne Susanna (Cornelia Zink) vor einem Altar, wie sie langsam aber sicher in sexuelle Ekstase gerät – die ganze Partitur ein einziges Crescendo – bis sie einer Glaubensschwester und deren hochgerecktem Kreuz samt Keuschheits- und Gehorsamsforderung entgegenschmettert: „Ich bin schön!“ und auch den anderen herbeigeeilten Nonnen die Beichte mit dreifachem Nein verweigert. Die schreien „Satana!“, doch Susanne steht in „unberührter Hoheit“: „So helfe mir mein Heiland gegen den euren!“</p>
<p>Dahinter hat längst Holzingers eigene Crew das Geschehen übernommen. Wo Hindemith, Sigmund Freuds Traumdeutung im Sinn, eine einzelne Spinne als Symbol für unterdrückte Sexualität über den Altar krabbeln lässt, klettern nun nackte Performerinnen die Rückwand hoch, küssen und lieben sich, ein Relief der offenen Lust, ein Venusberg.</p>
<p>Der Teufel kommt, das Kruzifix hängt über Kopf, alles ist rot, ein bisschen Nebel und ein bisschen Heavy Metal, das muss die Hölle sein. Ein Kranroboter hält mal das Ewige Licht, mal ein Kreuz, dient später als Weindusche und dreht eine Päpstin um die eigene Achse. Halbnackte Nonnen disko-rollern in der Halfpipe, „Kyrie Eleison“ singt der Chor der Schwestern. Bei Holzinger sind keine Symbole zu enträtseln – diese Feier des Direkten ist gänzlich unverschlüsselt.</p>
<p>Derweil kommt Jesus himself durchs Foyer gestampft, zankt sich unsanft ohne Eintrittskarte durch die Tür und kapert das Geschehen. Ein ziemlicher Dionysos ist dieser Heiland (Annina Machaz); ein zauseliger Althippie, der mit über die Schultern geworfenem Schaf und starkem Schweizer Akzent das Publikum durch launige Stand-ups motiviert: „I love bleeding for you”. Zwischen all dem Klamauk gibt es auch ein paar urchristliche Ideen, denn wenn Jesus – staatenlos und ohne Bleibe – kein Outcast ist, wer ist es dann? Der Messias revoluzzert bis er schließlich das ihm anvertraute Lamm stranguliert. Hier steht einer, auf den ihr nicht bauen könnt. Irgendwann ist auch das genug, mit kurzem Dankeschön wird die Zeit des „Jesusplaining“ endgültig für beendet erklärt. Die neue Menschin steht am Horizont.</p>
<p>Zum Beispiel in Person der kleinwüchsigen Schauspielerin Saioa Alvarez Ruiz, die schon in <em>Ophelia Got Talent</em> eine zentrale Rolle spielte. Als Päpstin von zwei halbnackten roten Kardinälinnen begleitet, nutzt sie die Risse, die sich über den Sixtinischen Kapellengott auf der Bühnenrückwand ziehen, kurzerhand als Anlass für ein komplettes Remake – schon hangeln sich gelbbehelmte Bauarbeiterinnen die Wand hoch und hämmern bis nichts mehr übrig ist vom männlichen Himmelsbild. Wir sind beim „Sanctus“ angekommen: „Erfüllt sind Himmel und Erde von deiner Herrlichkeit“. Alvarez Ruiz erzählt von ihrem eigenen Operations-Martyrium; dass sie lebt, muss ein Wunder sein oder eine Strafe. Harter Realitätseinbruch – doch schon geht’s weiter mit einer Schöpfungsabrechnung (der Heilige Geist sucht einen mehr oder weniger freiwilligen Rippen-Spender im Publikum zur Herstellung von Eva) bevor wir beim „Credo“ ankommen. Zwei Rollschulfahrerinnen knallen gegeneinander und werden in kniender Gebetshaltung eingegipst.</p>
<p>Befreit von Hindemith mixt Holzinger Techno, Metal und Kompositionen von Johanna Doderer, Pop und Bach, Rachmaninow und Elektronik. Ballett trifft auf Disko, Rollerskating auf Las Vegas-Cabaret, Akrobatik auf Body Art. Dabei hangeln sich Orchester, Chor, Sängerinnen und Holzinger-Performer*innen gut zweieinhalb Stunden mehr oder weniger präzise entlang der vorgeschriebenen katholischen Messe-Liturgie von „Kyrie“ bis „Sanctus“ und Abendmahl. Passend, dass die Premiere (im allerdings protestantischen Schwerin) an Fronleichnam stattfindet, dem katholischen „Hochfest des allerheiligsten Leibes und Blutes Christi“ und der Verwandlung von Brot und Wein. Für Holzinger ein klares Leitmotiv – weniger wegen des Pappmaché-Baguettes, mit dem der fröhlich grantige Heiland herumfuchtelt, als wegen des Blutes natürlich, das – auch in alkoholischem Aggregatzustand – in Strömen fließt, mal aus Flaschen, mal als Dusche, mal als echte Wunde. Das Authentizitätsproblem der Weinverwandlung verbindet Katholische Kirche, Method Acting und David Copperfield. Über das Abendmahl als sublimierter Kannibalismus ist viel spekuliert worden, doch bei Holzinger bleibt da nichts im Vagen:  Groß auf Bildschirme übertragen wird ein klitzekleines Stückchen Fleisch aus einer Performerin geschnitten, in einer Pfanne kurz frittiert und einer Schwester zum Abendmahl serviert. Eine ungläubige Jüngerin legt den Finger in die Wunde. „God, we must talk”.</p>
<p>Der Einsatz ist real und körperlich spürbar. Holzingers Rückgriffe sind mehr als Referenzen auf jene österreichischen (und oft ziemlich machohaften) Aktionisten, die in den 1960er Jahren amerikanische Happening-Kunst um Blut und Schmerz erweiterten. Für Holzinger dienen sie vor allem dazu, uns Zuschauer*innen das Bewusstsein für die Realität, in der wir uns gemeinsam befinden, immer wieder um die Ohren zu knallen. Diesmal (wie bereits in anderen Performances zuvor) vor allem mit einem Wink in Richtung des Aktionskünstlers Wolfgang Flatz, der sich zu Silvester 1990 in einer zerstörten Synagoge in Tiflis zwischen zwei Stahlplatten wie Glockenschlägel pendeln ließ. Aufgehängt an durchs Fleisch gebohrten Haken läuten Holzinger und Luz De Luna Duran so das „Vater unser“ ein. Schmerz, Pathos und alberne Pointe fallen zusammen. Vielleicht ist das die wahre Selbstermächtigung.</p>
<p>Darin ähnelt, aber unterscheidet sich Florentina Holzinger auch von einem offensichtlichen Vorgänger. Nicht nur weil Ophelia Got Talent in der Berliner Volksbühne stattfand, wo achtzehn Jahre zuvor <em>Kunst und Gemüse</em> Premiere feierte, schwebte die Erinnerung an Christoph Schlingensief durch den Raum: Gameshow-Dramaturgien, die eigene Präsenz auf der Bühne, (seelische) Selbstentblößungen, Menschen mit diversen Körpern und Geistern, Skandalerwartung, Peinlichkeit und Jux, vor allem aber die völlige Abwesenheit von Zynismus, das Gefühl einer Gemeinschaft beim Leben und Arbeiten zuzuschauen.</p>
<p>Doch Schlingensiefs Kirche fehlte natürlich nicht nur der feministische Impuls, sie blieb auch immer eine Kirche der Angst, ein Ankämpfen gegen die Furcht, gegen die eigenen Abgründe und am Ende gegen den Tod. Dem ehemaligen Ministranten steckte der Katholizismus in den Knochen, er war Teil von ihm. Holzinger hingegen dient die Kirchenkritik lediglich als Sprungbrett; die Abrechnung erfolgt eher pflichtgemäß, Papst &amp; Co bieten vor allem ein Repertoire an Ritualen, Bildern und Kostümen. Die eigentliche Inspiration scheint mehr von Monty Python oder <em>Peaches Christ Superstar</em> zu kommen als vom bislang alles überdauernden Original.</p>
<p>Dennoch steht hinter all der folkloristischen Kirchenparodie am Ende eine Faszination, die über die Jahrhunderte in Graswurzelkirchen immer wieder aufbrach: Die Sehnsucht nach einer Ur-Community, nach frühchristlichem Nächstenliebe-Anarchismus. Und so ist all der Mummenschanz, all der Klamauk und Action vor allem Mittel zum Zweck einer Gemeinschaft, die Holzinger in ihren Arbeiten immer wieder neu begründet. Jede vermeintliche Provokation ist ein Paukenschlag zur Verkündung dieses Kollektivs. Eine Einladung. Dass es immer wieder gelingt, diesen Zusammenhalt zu erzeugen, auch in Schwerin, auch an der Oper, auch mit Opernsängerinnen, Chor, Orchester – das ist ja fast schon ein Pfingstwunder: Kurz vor Schluss, in einem Schlussbild, dass dann doch noch nicht das Ende ist, weil Holzinger uns nicht gern ein Ende finden lässt, sind alle auf der Bühne. Und nach und nach ziehen sich auch einige der Chordamen aus, die eine nur den Schleier, die andere das Oberteil, die nächste den ganzen Habit, jede wählt das Maß der Zugehörigkeit selbst. Und auch das Publikum ist eingeladen, zumindest stimmlich, und fällt ein in den Rocky Horror Picture Show-Gassenhauer: „Don’t dream it, be it!“</p>
<p><em>Sancta</em> ist so freudvoll, zugewandt und optimistisch, weil es um die Zukunft geht. Um die Imagination einer Welt, die man will und nicht ums Abarbeiten an dem, was man nicht will. Vielleicht hängt Holzingers Erfolg auch damit zusammen, dass sie schafft, was gerade weder offizieller Politik noch Aktivismus noch Kunst oft gelingt: Eine Utopie nicht nur zu zeigen, sondern auch zu leben und  eine Wahrheit schon allein dadurch zu schaffen, dass man sie formuliert, spielt, zeigt, lebt.</p>
<p>Theater – und sei es in einem klassizistischen Opernhaus – ist halt immer ein Medium der Versammlung, der temporären Gemeinschaft. Eine Kunstform, in der das Werk im Augenblick der Rezeption entsteht. Im Hier im Jetzt. Wenn „Don’t dream it, be it“ der inhaltliche (oder theologische) Kernsatz Holzingers Arbeiten ist, dann fasst ein anderes Zitat die ästhetische Essenz: „We nail you to this present moment like Jesus was nailed to the cross.” Amen.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>&#8222;My Leadership Model is Permanent Revolution“</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/my-leadership-model-is-permanent-revolution/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 11 Oct 2023 16:04:55 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=2246</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Wiener Festwochen’s new artistic director unpacks Vienna’s relationship with being provoked, making grotesque demands onstage, and the theater as a total democracy. Florian Malzacher: You’re a theater and film director, artist, activist, columnist, author&#8230; What appeals to you about being an artistic director to boot – first at the theater NTGent and now at the [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Wiener Festwochen’s new artistic director unpacks Vienna’s relationship with being provoked, making grotesque demands onstage, and the theater as a total democracy.</strong></p>
<p><strong>Florian Malzacher: You’re a theater and film director, artist, activist, columnist, author&#8230; What appeals to you about being an artistic director to boot – first at the theater NTGent and now at the Wiener Festwochen?</strong></p>
<p>Milo Rau: It’s just a different approach. In Ghent, it was simply interesting to say: I’m going to stop with only criticizing institutions – we do that all the time – and instead, I’m going to try to run one. Moreover, I’m going to bring in the things that I lack as an artist, and to implement them in such a way that it becomes the theater, or now the festival, where I myself would like to be. So I am taking more of an experimental approach.</p>
<p>In Ghent, for example, I tried to bring together the respective advantages of the independent scene and the municipal theater. To think at an even more fundamental level: How can you produce differently, tour differently, think of authorship differently, and be more transparent? And then you suddenly get to know the difficulties of institutions from within, their contradictions and their ponderousness. That leads to a certain humility with respect to the possibilities of institutions, which you often overestimate as an independent artist.</p>
<p>The most important thing is to leave at the right time. When I leave, I will have been artistic director in Ghent for almost seven years, and in Vienna, I have a five-year contract. With projects, it’s absolutely mandatory that they have a fixed end point. But institutions have this property of slowing down time, of creating bonds. Power accrues as a matter of course, no matter how much you try to distribute it. And you have to fight that radically – by leaving. If you first come to such institutions later on in life, as in my case, then maybe it’s easier. I’ve always been good at changing gears and starting again, because that’s the logic of both theater and activism.</p>
<p>We’ve really created a tabula rasa in Ghent and built different production structures – it’s a dream of a theater, open to all, and present all over the world as much as it is in the city itself. The changes that are coming now – for example, that there is a consistent focus on diversity in hiring practices, that the buildings are finally being renovated – I can theoretically do those things, but they’re not my original, innermost talents. So it’s quite natural that someone else will now take those next steps.</p>
<p><strong>The hassles of implementing and maintaining standards are not your fortes?</strong></p>
<p>What always motivated me in Ghent was the antagonism. I had to realize that the structure rejects me, that the city has a problem, that Flanders either has to get used to it or that there would be conflict. After a few years, everyone came to love me, and I came to love everyone. I got an honorary doctorate, I am a friend of the mayor. That’s when I realized: Now it’s time for me to go.</p>
<p>It also has to be said that running artistic institutions is not rocket science. You’re surrounded by a lot of smart people who also want to change things. Of course, there are the right-wing politicians on NTGent’s Board of Directors, plus the bourgeois critics, whom you can never quite please – and in Vienna, of course, it’s more complicated yet. That has to do with the size, the money, and the traditions of the city and the festival.</p>
<p><strong>There seems to be a great longing in Vienna for Intendanten who are themselves artists. Is there any truth to this notion? To what extent are you still an artist when you are an artistic director? And what do you see differently from dramaturge-directors, curators, or cultural managers?</strong></p>
<p>I don’t know if such a separation exists, though there are poles, of course. The difference between me and my financial co-director in Ghent is that he really is a leader. He is always trying to mediate, to consolidate, and I’m not a leader in that sense. I always try to build reality according to a collective vision: My leadership model is a permanent revolution. I think that leading institutions means showing why they exist. Of course, that’s also the case in Vienna, where I immediately think: What is a festival, really, and why is there a festival at all – and not, rather, no festival?</p>
<p>I think the classic model of curation – that is, which understands the festival as a vessel for a mixture of products – is outdated. For me, a festival is a collective machine for living, production, and emotion. But maybe I’m more of a sociologist than a theater director.</p>
<p>If you look at what a classical director like Martin Kušej is doing with the Burgtheater, it’s simple: Everything that doesn’t say Shakespeare or Nestroy on it is an academic side program and has to go. He simply wants a lot of screaming on stage, a lot of staging. And that is the danger of the artist-director, that the playbill becomes the playing field of a very one-sided aesthetic. In a city theater or a festival, you need generosity and openness. I learned in Ghent that many productions that are well-received and objectively important are also not the ones I would go to see first. But an ideal artistic institution is total democracy: Not the critics, not the directors, but the city and the audience are always right.</p>
<p><strong>You mentioned before that you are attracted by the possibility of making concrete changes as the head of an institution. As an artist, on the other hand, you can make big, radical demands that you don’t necessarily have to implement yourself. In some respects, the artist Milo Rau has to make fewer compromises than the artistic director Milo Rau. This used to be less relevant in political theater some years ago, because one usually wasn’t accused of the discrepancy between the demands onstage and the reality backstage. That has changed – and you also postulate quite clearly that the institution itself must meet the demands made of it. Is it possible to do both at once: to make maximalist demands onstage while undertaking the slow boring of hard boards?</strong></p>
<p>It goes even further than that: The entire life we lead under capitalism is a false, destructive, and, in the end, apocalyptic life. And yet we demand another one. Pablo Casella, the composer of Antigone in the Amazon (2023), has said: “In this generation, we cannot get out of this performative contradiction.” But we still have to demand another world. When the world ends, it will be better if we have at least imagined a better world.</p>
<p>I think it’s important to play out the necessary conflicts within the projects, to expose oneself to the contradictions, but also pragmatically to try to change things. Take Antigone in the Amazon, for example. We will tour that an insane amount, through one hundred cities in two years. The money from the authors’ rights goes directly to the Movimento dos Trabalhadores Rurais Sem Terra (Landless Workers Movement) in Brazil, and they decide what to do with it. That is very concrete. It’s also important to formulate concrete standards against which your own actions can be measured, so that others can also demand them of you.</p>
<p>One of the big problems of our time is that we have a very moralistic, partly paranoid discourse onstage; that we demand a lot, as you said, but that we often don’t know how to break that down and implement it concretely. That’s the reason I decided to do collective institutional work. Nevertheless, I believe one should never stop making the most grotesque and maximalist demands for the good life on stage. Because that&#8217;s what it’s there for.</p>
<p><strong>In the end, you are still a white man who is at the top of the hierarchy, however flat it may be. And that in a city where, oftentimes, artistic directors have been considered almost monarchs.</strong></p>
<p>The dramaturges and production managers are autonomous. Only when there’s a really big problem does it reach the ears of the artistic directors, because you simply have to take on certain responsibilities – otherwise, it’s not safe for the team. But this grassroots democratic structure is extremely difficult to establish; it took years in Ghent. In Vienna, I am fortunate to be coming into a very self-confident team of smart and incredibly professional people, to which I am now just adding my part. I try to give direction with a vision and some projects that I do myself. But what idea do I have, for example, about music? Or about Austria?</p>
<p><strong>Milo Rau may be many, but in the end, it says Milo Rau, who not only earns a higher fee, but also gains symbolic capital. Had you considered applying to Wiener Festwochen as a collective? Or is it important for you, in the end, to have the final decision?</strong></p>
<p>Let me first say something about symbolic capital: I’ve already managed to give NTGent this symbolic power, so that, for example, directors like Miet Warlop suddenly have an international career that they didn’t have before. We produced a play of hers, placed one of them in Avignon [One Song, 2022], which was covered by the New York Times – and we do that with quite a lot of artists and activists. In Ghent, we use the theater as a machine to bring peripheral positions right into the center; my name and my network help in that respect, of course. The question with symbolic capital is always: What do you invest it in? That is also my plan with the Festwochen: To create a symbolic power for this festival, and to bring peripheral positions onto the big stage.</p>
<p>On the question of the collective application: At this moment in time, that would have had no chance in Vienna – I was advised against it. That said, while my name clearly comes first, it was still an application from a group, that is, together with the dramaturges and so on. For me, the real collective is the whole team, anyway: all the production managers, all the technicians, the hundred people in the Festwochen, and all of our partners. The so-called “collective leadership” as one knows it in some institutions, which always includes two or three friends, is almost more of a hardening, a strengthening of the top against the base, isn’t it?</p>
<p><strong>The curatorial collective WHW did not have a real chance in Vienna, it seems. [Editor’s note: three members of the all-women, Zagreb-based curatorial collective What, How &amp; for Whom were appointed artistic directors of Vienna’s Kunsthalle Wien in June 2019; the city council announced this past December that their five-year contract would be allowed to expire next summer without extension.]</strong></p>
<p>They simply “failed” because of COVID. We’re doing an exhibition together next spring. They’re anything but failed: In fact, it’s only just getting started with them.</p>
<p>But basically: We Europeans invented the strong individual in the history of mankind and celebrated it over the course of three thousand years. It’s just difficult now to suddenly say, okay, the whole thing was destructive and psycho and a bit toxic, now it’s over. And with Europe, I’m thinking of the whole world that we Europeans colonized. Take Lula in Brazil, for example – he seems irreplaceable.</p>
<p><strong>What are the functions of an international festival today? Such large-scale events are heavily criticized – and for many good reasons, from the attitude of simply shopping internationally for productions, kerosene consumption, and a lack of sustainability, to questions about the colonial, exoticizing view of art and their outdated universalism. How do you deal with this?</strong></p>
<p>In Ghent, we tried to maintain a balance between internationality and localism, between invitations and our own productions. We also invited groups that are absolutely essential locally but unknown abroad, as well as works that we felt were important to show in Ghent. It’s a question of balance.</p>
<p>In Vienna, the size of the city alone means that it’s full of crazy characters, artists, and activists. Vienna is simply an incredibly interesting city. And then there’s its proximity to Eastern Europe! For the last twenty years, I have concentrated on the Global South, which, owing to colonialism, is an inescapable given in Belgium. Now, in Vienna, I suddenly have the feeling that I’ve been looking at the world too one-sidedly.</p>
<p>Vienna is the second-largest German-speaking city in the world, the fourth-largest city in Europe, and such a juggernaut and painstaking apparatus of tradition, while at the same time having this legacy of modernity. I ask myself: What kind of city is this? Because I always work very directly from context. Then there’s the city’s Jewish past, but also its anti-Semitic past, its imperial past, the inward and outward flows of migration, and the fact that half the population immigrated from Eastern and Southeastern Europe. I’m totally up for investigating all of these things.</p>
<p><strong>Since you’re talking about Viennese traditions: There’s also a strange love-hate relationship here with provocation, which you certainly have a reputation for delivering. Isn’t that bringing owls to Athens?</strong></p>
<p>Some cities actually seem better suited for provocations than others. If you look at Christoph Schlingensief in Zurich with the former neo-Nazis performing Hamlet and in Vienna with the deportation container for asylum-seekers, then you have to say: That didn’t work in Zurich. Vienna is a reactive space, and the artists and the audience are geared to the extreme, from Viennese Actionism to Elfriede Jelinek and Florentina Holzinger. A normal city would say: We’ve had modernism, psychoanalysis, twelve-tone music, anti-Semitism, the Habsburg monarchy, Jörg Haider, and Florian Teichtmeister – but that’s enough now. But Vienna asks: Into what hopeless mess may we plunge tomorrow? That will offer me the vital counterpoint I need.</p>
<p><strong>Especially since the political situation is just getting worse.</strong></p>
<p>Austria has decided to dive deep into fascism once again – it’s happening right now in some states, and it will happen at the federal level next year, probably. Then, Austria will again become the laboratory of right-wing populism, which is even more aggressive, which minces words even less than it did in 2000, when Schlingensief came with the containers. I have lived for a long time in Western Europe, which still indulges in certain illusions. But Austria is Central Europe, and Central Europe has done away with all illusions. There is a saying: If the world should end someday, I’ll go to Vienna, where I will still have another fifty years. But in terms of the decay of Western democracy, Austria is always at least ten years further ahead of everyone else toward the end of the world.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><strong>MILO RAU is the artistic director of Wiener Festwochen and, until the end of the 2022/23 season, NTGent. He is also the author of approximately fifteen books, the director of numerous award-winning films, and the founder of the International Institute of Political Murder.  </strong></p>
<p><strong>FLORIAN MALZACHER is a curator, writer, and dramaturg, as well as the host of the lecture series “The Art of Assembly.” His most recent book is The Art of Assembly. Political Theater Today (2023). He lives in Berlin.</strong></p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Revisiting Frakcija 55 &#8222;Curating Performing Arts&#8220;</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/revisiting-frakcija-55-curating-performing-arts/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 14 Jan 2023 15:19:37 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1970</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[TURBA: I’m really curious about the origins of Frakcija No. 55. We don’t know what motivated it, how it all came together in the beginning, and especially, why did it happen at that time and not twenty years earlier? Petra Zanki (PZ): It started at the Choreographic Platform Austria in Graz 2009. Florian was talking [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>TURBA: I’m really curious about the origins of <em>Frakcija</em> No. 55. We don’t know what motivated it, how it all came together in the beginning, and especially, why did it happen at that time and not twenty years earlier?</strong></p>
<p><strong>Petra Zanki (PZ):</strong> It started at the <em>Choreographic Platform Austria</em> in Graz 2009. Florian was talking to a programmer and she said, “Oh, I wish these dancers ‘would do something’ for us.” And we were talking and talking, and I just thought how interesting they were, the group of people who were there. And they were all curators. I was a choreographer and dancer. So, I thought how interesting it would be to make something. At the time I saw the piece that Tea had made with the reading by Marguerite Duras, <em>La maladie de la mort</em>. I was obsessed with that . . . how beautiful it was, and I wanted to meet this person, Tea. Then we went to Graz, and it was all this new world. I reached out to her because I really wanted to do it with somebody else, share the idea of a curator’s piece. And that’s how it started.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: You said there were a lot of curators there at that platform. Were they calling themselves curators?</strong></p>
<p><strong>Florian Malzacher (FM):</strong> No, I guess that is the point. My colleagues were usually rather referring to themselves as programmers, program directors, etc. There was a certain distrust of the term with its origin in the visual arts. A feeling that there was something pretentious about it—and that it was perhaps competing with the role of an artists. On the other hand, with a group of former theater studies students from Giessen, we had already founded in 2000 in Frankfurt the curators’ collective Unfriendly Takeover. I am not even sure why we called ourselves curators. Maybe inspired by Hans-Ulrich Obrist, an important reference at that time. When I joined steirischer herbst festival in Graz in 2006 “curator” was part of my offi cial title. But within the performing arts that was rather rare.</p>
<p><strong>Tea Tupajić (TT):</strong> We purposely chose it for our performance work <em>The Curators’ Piece</em> that was performed by a cast of international curators. But the framework for the performance, conceptually and also structurally later on, was the notion of a “trial against art,” in which Petra and I took as a premise that we accused art of being guilty because it hadn’t saved the world. And the one thing that was necessary to understand about the root of that is that we come from the former Yugoslavia. Our wars were in the 1990s, and we were also quite young when we made <em>The Curators’ Piece</em>. We were raised by watching the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia on the television. In the forefront of our minds, of course, was the question of responsibility. It’s a metaphorical question: “Who was the one who was supposed to save our world from wars?” And so, when we opened the discussion on <em>The Curators’ Piece</em>, we really focused on the idea of responsibility. What is your responsibility within the program choices that you’re making, as well as what kind of consequences do your choices have for society? Quite often, the curators were reluctant to call themselves curators. They called themselves a bridge between artists and an audience, a friend of the artist, whatever. But when we said, no, you do have a responsibility and you have to assume it. It’s then that the conversation rose to another level, and it also enabled this issue of Frakcija to be framed in that way.</p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> Well, to be honest, aft er all these years, I still don’t understand why, in this trial, curators defended art and not artists. As if they were the legal representatives of art. Was it to prove that the curators were the reason for all the misery in the world? [laughs]</p>
<p><strong>TT:</strong> It’s one of those questions that is impossible to answer. I think it has a lot to do with the history of our trials, that we were constantly, historically, trying to find someone to blame. You keep going higher up the responsibility ladder. This is how we came to the curator. S/he was also a symbolic, imaginary figure of somebody who could have made certain choices.</p>
<p><strong>PZ:</strong> I believe it was also about a certain time, because suddenly seeing, at least for me, so many curators in one place at the Austrian platform who were talking about works of art. They were all from festivals or [production] houses. It was they who were choosing the artists. It was important for us to ask them questions. The curators have more power than the artists.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: Another question was about the symposium <em>Beyond Curating: Strategies of Knowledge Transfer in Dance, Performance, and Visual Arts</em> in Essen, Germany, in that same year. Were you all involved in that as well? It was focused on dance and visual arts. We were wondering why theater and music weren’t at the table for that issue of <em>Frakcija</em>.</strong></p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> I am surprised to hear you say that. For me this edition was mainly about theater—but I have a very wide definition of theater. It can also include parts of choreography, performance art, installation art, etc. And we had authors from very different fields. For me the issue could also have been called “Curating Theater”—but of course that would have created misunderstandings. You are right though that we had no focus on music specifically.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: We had only four presenters from contemporary music and sound arts at our 2014 symposium on performing arts curation in Montreal because the whole discourse on curation hadn’t seemed to have emerged yet in that fi eld. But we wonder, was there a connection then between the Essen conference and your journal?</strong></p>
<p><strong>PZ:</strong> Something happened before that, at the International Network for Contemporary Performing arts meeting when we really started working on <em>The Curators’ Piece</em>. We talked to Florian about how we could make this piece happen with the ten curators I had met. And Tea liked the idea. The suggestion first came from Florian to visit this event in Berlin.</p>
<p><strong>TT:</strong> I think by that time we had already published <em>Frakcija</em>, and that this is why they invited us for the presentation.</p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> We should just clarify that The Curators’ Piece is not the same thing as this edition of Frakcija. <em>The Curators’ Piece</em> came first, as an idea. It is a performance directed by Petra and Tea, I was just one of the performers. The concept for a special issue of <em>Frakcija</em>, the work of the three of us, was developed in parallel.</p>
<p><strong>PZ:</strong> They invited us to the <em>Beyond Curating</em> conference to present our work. We started the conversation, and we asked a couple of people to work on the glossary of terms.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: In another vein, Yves Sheriff, one of TURBA’s editors, was very impacted by this issue of <em>Frakcija </em>at the time it came out. So, a decade later he asks, “Where do you think the outpourings or retractions and the identity territories that are shaping curatorial projects stand now? Have the preliminary suggestions for performing arts curation suggested in <em>Frakcija</em> been quickly overtaken by the margins of a new representation of the world, or have they caught on and so established themselves as models?” What do you think the impact of the journal has been?</strong></p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> Well, the question of impact is complex of course. Yes, the magazine played a role in forming the discourse but it was also a moment in time when things emerged in different ways, initiated by various people. There was momentum, and <em>Frakcija</em> was part of this. And in the last ten years the discourse has evolved as has the curatorial praxis, especially with younger generations.</p>
<p><strong>TT:</strong> It’s my impression that the biggest contribution that <em>Frakcija</em> made at the moment is that it established the concept of curator. The curator stopped being this ambiguous bridge between an artist and an audience. When we first started the project, it was perceived as something that would put a curator and the artist in a conflictual power relationship. And nobody wanted to be in that power relationship. After <em>The Curators’ Piece</em> and <em>Frakcija</em>, a lot of educational programs were founded in this new fi eld of curating. So, the biggest difference I see now is that people are deliberately using and claiming the title.</p>
<p><strong>PZ:</strong> We were really surprised when we started doing this and were looking for other resources that we didn’t find any. It’s an interesting thing to be the first publication ever on the subject of curating performing arts. The first edition sold out quickly to universities everywhere in the world! And then we came to them saying, “Hey, we should probably do a second edition.” We published a second edition, but then budgets and funding were tight, so we couldn’t do more.</p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> <em>Frakcija</em> came at a moment when things started changing in the way in which festivals were perceived and what role curatorial thinking could play. It was not a sudden change, and it happened rather with the emergence of a new generation of curators. And an even younger generation today is very much informed by it—and, I would say, often even more by the discourse than by praxis. But maybe this is also already changing again since paradigms are shifting fast. Obviously, there is much more diversity, collective curating, and so on. These changes in curatorial discourse provide a lot of possibilities. In <em>Frakcija</em> we had a conversation with an older generation of curators, producers, theater scholars in which they described the beginning of many festivals and venues in Europe in the 1980s. It was clear: basically, none of the protagonists of that time was interested in curatorial concepts. A conversation with young protagonists today would be very different.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: On a similar note, another co-editor of TURBA, Sandeep Bhagwati, asks, “Could you expand on the subject of the usefulness or uselessness of providing theses through curation in the live arts? Have you seen, and maybe pursued, more fruitful approaches to curating live arts and to writing about it in the years since?”</strong></p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> I used to be a theater critic before becoming a curator, and that informed my understanding of the work quite a bit. You always refer to concrete artistic works, your thinking is developed from concrete works. A lot of writing in theater studies, at least at that time, worked the other way around. One had a thesis and then looked for work to prove this theory.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: There is the exception of the artist-curators, of course, writing about their practice.</strong></p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> Yes, but what is actually even more interesting than artists curating a festival or a venue is how curatorial thinking has entered artistic work itself. There are quite a few artists that see their artistic work at least partly as a curatorial process. For me that is much more productive than the increased curatorial discourse that circles mainly around itself, especially in the visual arts.</p>
<p><strong>TT:</strong> I agree strongly with Florian’s thoughts and desires. That was such a beautiful and precious time. We’re from a time when writing about art came from watching art. I would be really interested in raising consciousness and awareness of all this knowledge that curators from the previous generations have, like those from the 1980s and 1990s. They were practitioners who understood art through watching a lot of art. They were also involved in the practical problems of creating festivals and connecting the art to their communities. It would be really nice to tap into that knowledge and make it into a discourse.</p>
<p><strong>PZ:</strong> I was thinking in a completely opposite direction. So you call TURBA hybrid. And I was thinking, how interesting it would be to see where that specific form can go in a more experimental way so that it’s not only about what it means to be curating, but how that process can evolve into something else completely. It would be more interesting to see what kind of hybrid forms are happening there in the future and that are completely dissolving the form and creating new things.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: Moving on to co-editor Tawny Andersen’s question, “How has the institutionalization of the performing arts affected the role of the live arts curator, the economy and ecology of the performing arts world?”</strong></p>
<p><strong>PZ:</strong> We often think this system in which I’m living right now in the US is the harshest. In Italy, it’s the harshest of all the systems because it doesn’t allow for artists to fail and experiment as much. It only allows for success. So you measure yourself in terms of that success. Otherwise, you’re not able to survive or, you just move to Europe. I lived through different systems like socialism/ communism, and there were no arts other than state art or folklore. And then things started changing, evolving; individualism was allowed. And then we moved to Western Europe, finally becoming a part of something that we had all dreamed about. And then with the same idea of an American dream, you moved to America because you only see the shiny part, and then you see the downside. But you learn to live with it. I choose to live here, although it’s very difficult for me.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: And so, where is everyone’s home right now?</strong></p>
<p><strong>TT:</strong> I’m in Amsterdam.</p>
<p><strong>PZ:</strong> I’m in Brooklyn.</p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> Berlin.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: And where do you think the art world has moved in the last decade?</strong></p>
<p><strong>FM:</strong> That’s actually the hidden question in this conversation. If <em>Frakcija</em> would be published now, what would be its obvious shortcomings? Let’s say there are three dominant topics at the moment. The first are the questions about postcolonialism, which we did address through an Eastern European perspective. But besides this, the topic was absent, and the word isn’t mentioned. Secondly, can you imagine a publication not having the word identity politics in it today? And, in a way, related to that, there is the question of collective curating. Which is a big thing for younger curators. Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, there is the question of the climate catastrophe. Environmental questions appear in <em>Frakcija</em> a little, but they are not the main issue as they hopefully would be today. But—actually, I am rather happy and surprised that all of these topics are at least present somewhere in the publication. Obviously today they would have to play a much more central role.</p>
<p><strong>TURBA: I really like that reflection as a last set of critical thoughts. What a lovely reunion.</strong></p>
<p class="info"><strong>Florian Malzacher is a performing arts curator, dramaturge and writer, a graduate of the Institute for Applied Theater Studies at the University of Giessen. Current projects include Training for the Future (with Jonas Staal) and the discourse platform The Art of Assembly. Among his recent publications are Empty Stages, Crowded Flats: Performativity as Curatorial Strategy (2017, with Joanna Warsza), and <em>Gesellschaftsspiele: Politisches Theater heute</em> (2020, English edition forthcoming).</strong></p>
<p class="info"><strong>Tea Tupajić is a theater and fi lm director, who studied at the Academy of Dramatic Art in Zagreb. She initiates long-lasting projects exploring the potential of art when encountered with complex political issues. Her projects <em>The Curators’ Piece</em> (2011, with Petra Zanki), <em>Variete Europe</em> (2013), <em>The Disco</em> (2015), <em>Spy School</em> (2015), <em>DARK NUMBERS</em> (2018), <em>and Bosnian Girl</em>(2021) were presented internationally.</strong></p>
<p class="info"><strong>Petra Zanki is choreographer and theater maker living in Brooklyn, New York, graduate in Comparative Literature and French from the University of Arts and Philosophy in Zagreb. Her performance works include <em>Paces</em> (2010), <em>The Curators’ Piece</em>(2011, with Tea Tupajić), and <em>Pleasant Place</em> (2019). Growing up in Croatia during the war, Petra’s interest remains the transformation of pain into landscapes of beauty for the benefit of humanity.</strong></p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“A tool to develop oppositional ideas, and not to be afraid”</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/a-tool-to-develop-oppositional-ideas-and-not-to-be-afraid/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 11 Jan 2023 14:58:14 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/a-tool-to-develop-oppositional-ideas-and-not-to-be-afraid/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Tunis, 23 November 2011 Talking to bloggers from Tunis has become a rather popular activity for politicians, curators etc.… Yes, we have become a classic. I have met prime ministers, ministers, even Ban Ki Moon, the UN Secretary-General – twice already. There seems to be a need to come to Tunis and to present yourself [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Tunis, 23 November 2011</strong></p>
<p><strong>Talking to bloggers from Tunis has become a rather popular activity for politicians, curators etc.…</strong></p>
<p>Yes, we have become a classic. I have met prime ministers, ministers, even Ban Ki Moon, the UN Secretary-General – twice already. There seems to be a need to come to Tunis and to present yourself with symbolic figures from the revolution. Our worry is that all this is useless, that it doesn’t change anything… Too often our meetings are just photo opportunities. That’s why most of us don’t really want to talk to politicians or foreign journalists anymore.<br />
But we need to communicate, we must spread information that can be helpful and that can inspire people by the Tunisian battle. Even if it is frustrating to get misquoted and being used for arguments, that are not your own. I once told a French journalist that I don’t follow any religion but that I respect it. He made out of me a convinced secular. No! I am not fighting for secularity. I don’t think that secularism is crucial for the survival of the Tunisian democracy.</p>
<p><strong>The grounds for Internet activism in Tunisia had been prepared already a few years before for the actual revolution. It did not just appear out of nowhere…</strong></p>
<p>It even started already around 1995 in forums etc. after a campaign by the Tunisian government promoting the new technology. Ben Ali was fanatic about everything that had to do with technology. Some say he was an enemy of the internet but in fact he was an enemy of free expression, and not the Internet.<br />
For us it soon became the only space where we could express ourselves. We used it as a tool to develop oppositional ideas, and not to be afraid. You must realize: When we spoke about politics, we whispered. Even a couple in bed, in complete intimacy – when they spoke about politics, they whispered!<br />
Our aim was to create a debate to go against this taboo –politics was a taboo–, to pose questions, to demystify politics. Facebook started in Tunisia in 2007 – by the end of 2008 we were already more than 1.5 million users. Now we are 3 million – of a population of 10 million. Egypt had much less Internet users, but they were encouraged by the Tunisian revolution.</p>
<p><strong>How was the internet used as a tool against fear?</strong></p>
<p>In 2008, there was the rebellion in Gafsa/Redeyef, a region in the South of Tunisia, which was crushed by the government. A journalist had filmed the events with a standard camera. We took these images and circulated them via Facebook. In the beginning this was not easy, because people did not share the videos out of fear to be put in prison. So, it was up to us cyber dissidents to invade this tool and express oppositional opinions. We stepped over the red line that had kept people from participating – and with this the line became more and more transparent. People slowly started to use Facebook, to participate in the critique of the government, to express dissent. All this was happening already when the in late 2010 the events in Tunis happened. It was not a spontaneous reaction. Without the slow development beforehand the people would have never dared to do this. The change that took place was also a result of demystifying the dangers of the web and of the possible threats posed by Ben Ali. People took little steps towards an unknown terrain and stopped having fear. And shortly after the print media took over the provocations toward the government.</p>
<p><strong>So what was the connection between the offline and the online revolution? A lot of people did not use the internet at all and still pushed for the revolution.</strong></p>
<p>In this case, we don’t deserve the laurels. The web world helped the real world in its struggle, but the web world didn’t start the revolution. It contributed to the breeding ground and accompanied it by giving it a certain strength. This revolution couldn’t have existed on a purely technological level, but it was way to spread the information: Where did we learn about the death of Mohamed Bouazizi, who burned himself? In the web, on Facebook. Where did we learn about what happened at his funeral? In the web. Where did we read about the reaction of the police? In the web. There were people who filmed and who understood the impact of the image, who understood where to post it to receive maximum exposure. In this regard, we facilitated the movement. The proof are the events of 2008 in Gafsa. They were not accompanied by the web and were crushed and oppressed in silence.</p>
<p><strong>Many people overcame their fear in the net – but still there was very real danger – people were arrested, tortured. What was the government’s strategy: Why did they arrest certain people and others not?</strong></p>
<p>There is the story of Zouheir Yahyaoui, who was the first cyber-dissident to be pursued and condemned in Tunisia, when the country was at the top of lists of internet policing. He founded and edited one of the first open discussion forums on the internet the satirical website Tunezine. It gathered people across the political spectrum discussing women’s issues, human rights, economic problems, freedom of expression or religion. Yahyaoui got arrested in 2002 for creating the site and was sentenced to two years in prison. [He died of a heart attack in 2005 at the age of 37 and became a symbol for the internet dissent.] He was one of the first to use this tool effectively. The internet had become a real threat to the government – and I was determined to continue what he had begun.<br />
Later when we were imprisoned ourselves in the Ministry of the Internal Affairs, we were not treated like the others. They knew what it meant to arrest a blogger: We didn’t miss an occasion to remind them of the death of Zouheir Yahyaoui. It remained a thorn in the foot of the regime. Sometimes he is considered a prophet in the whole fight, a symbol of the suffering.</p>
<p><strong>The arrests were selective – how and why did you get into prison?</strong></p>
<p>When I look at the arrests of all of us on January 6th, 2011, it is clear that they were very calculating. Everyone of us who got arrested, represented a different key position in the Internet resistance. They picked me because I was considered the leader of the influential Facebook group. But there are no leaders or moderators on Facebook, so I confronted them with this argument. They said that I was one of agitators.<br />
By arresting one of each group, they wanted to stop and intimidate all the others within these groups. And indeed there was panic. Before even our families knew about our arrests, there was the announcement of it on Facebook. It was the ministry itself who announced it on Facebook!</p>
<p><strong>So they were in the game, too!</strong></p>
<p>Yes, completely. Some of my “friends” on Facebook were agents of the Ministry for Internal Affairs. Ben Ali’s dictatorship was a technocratic regime – they had the competence to censor and to infiltrate. By arresting us they wanted to scare people and stop them from sharing their views online. But they miscalculated. It stimulated people even more. Even those who initially weren’t involved now joined the discussions.</p>
<p><strong>Usually administrations rather have problems keeping up with technical developments.</strong></p>
<p>It was not the administration, it’s the police: If you let the police anywhere in the world do whatever they please, they will install microphones wherever they can. In Tunisia they didn’t need papers for anything. So the regime had their pirates, their engineers and best technicians working for them. The cyber war between the regime and the cyber dissent was like a game of chess. It was a war between one intelligence against the other. Our advantage was that we defended something defendable, and they didn’t.</p>
<p><strong>How did Facebook become the perfect tool to mobilize the people?</strong></p>
<p>First it was just used for information – to maintain contacts as well, but mainly to follow what was going on. The public media were censored, and outside of the internet most people didn’t dare to criticize the regime, but in a private sphere they did more and more. And since people use their computers generally in a more private context, at home, on the table, even in bed, they feel like they can be more themselves. The discussions that happened on Facebook would not have happened on the street. Nobody can listen to a chat. So people talked about things they otherwise would never mention. And slowly that broke the barriers also towards the other means of the internet like Facebook. Social media is world media, and it can serve during the revolution.</p>
<p><strong>The internet took over the role of newspapers, radio, television as critical media.</strong></p>
<p>The idea of independent journalism got lost during the dictatorship. That’s why we started our work as analysts, as critics, as reporters – we did everything. It was dangerous, so whoever did that was clearly determined. That gave the whole movement its gravity. Soon we were infiltrated by the State Police that fed us with wrong information in order to discredit our reliability. But we learned fast from these mistakes and were more careful.<br />
After January 14th, 2011, it was save to do all this – and some people believed that being a cyber activist was a good way to get famous. Suddenly people without any experience distributed information they never verified – this did cost us a lot of our credibility. The field changed and we have to adapt to this again. Now I am founding together with some people an association for Tunisian bloggers, with the aim to write and explain the history of cyber activism before and during the revolution. We want to create a kind of anthology to give back the respect to this movement, which is an important part of Tunisian history and is missing in the books so far.</p>
<p><strong>The political role of bloggers and other cyber activists has become less important after the liberation of the press. But are the journalists prepared for their new role?</strong></p>
<p>Now it is up to the newspapers. We, the bloggers, laid down our arms. Facebook will become a tool merely for fun.</p>
<p><strong>But Facebook is not exactly an innocent medium itself. Weren’t you skeptical to add to its success?</strong></p>
<p>In Nice at the G20 I found myself in midst old militant leftists who rejected the internet as an American instrument to police the people. For them Facebook is just a big corporation. But I don’t care about the tool I use. I am interested in what I can do with it. Facebook exists with and through us. Do I have to stop using Facebook even though no better tool exists at the moment – just because it benefits Mark Zuckerberg? I never cared whether Facebook benefits from me. Quite the opposite. I see that I am supporting an initiative that gives the freedom to create change in the world. Zuckerberg is making a fortune because he is smarter than others. That doesn’t bother me. One must enter the system to change it. Mark Zuckerberg makes money of Facebook – so what: I am also wearing jeans that have been fabricated elsewhere and that someone makes money of.</p>
<p><strong>But your jeans don’t collect data and makes public everything you do.</strong></p>
<p>Yes. But I cannot say I don’t share information with my friends, just because I fear this tool. Of course I don’t upload photos from everywhere I am, I don’t tell people all the time what I do. I restrict myself. But it seems a lot of people like their lives to be public.</p>
<p><strong>It might be related to the aspect of intimacy that Facebook produces and that helped to use it as a political instrument. People tend to consider Facebook as private not as public space.</strong></p>
<p>That’s why I am promoting the political aspect of it. We should use it responsibly rather then condemning it.</p>
<p><strong>Let’s go back to the revolution. Can you recall the days before it started? You got into prison…</strong></p>
<p>… that was one of the worst moments in my life. You imagine yourself going into prison for ten years or more. When I came out on January 9th, 2011, the first thing I thought of, was to go home, grab my things, and to escape to a place where nobody could find me. So I went to the old part of the city and hid at friends’ places. Then the events leading to the revolution happened, there were fights on the street. I saw young people on the ground, I saw cars being destroyed. I saw women who threw gas bottles out of the window on the police – a real street fight. In the evening, we went back home and commented everything on the net.<br />
On the evening of the 13th there was the last speech of Ben Ali. And shortly after demonstrations throughout Tunisia started to show that that we thought Ben Ali was a liar. And to challenge him and put him under pressure.<br />
On the 14th I participated in the demonstration in front of the Ministry of Interior – the images of this demonstration are known all over the world. For me it was quite funny, because I just had gotten out of this building where I was imprisoned. Later we were evacuated, beaten with sticks, and attacked with tear gas. The same day Ben Ali escaped, the militia strolled through the city and intimidated everyone. So there wasn’t a moment of joy. We didn’t celebrate the escape of Ben Ali. We directly passed on, time accelerated very fast.<br />
When the first new government was installed, it claimed to purge the government of the elements of the previous regime. The Committee for the realisation of the principles of the revolution [Haute instance pour la réalisation des objectifs de la révolution, de la réforme politique et de la transition démocratique] was created and I was appointed to be a member as representative for the activist community. Suddenly I found myself in a world, in which I would never have thought to be in: Directly on the other side of politics, like in a dream. Parallel to this the media solicited me, as well as researchers, students, and foreigners who wanted to study the role of cyber dissent.</p>
<p><strong>The first Arab Spring tourists arrived.</strong></p>
<p>Exactly. The journalists were the first one to arrive, and right after them the Arab Spring tourists. It was a bit funny. Suddenly we were for example contacted by the British Embassy to come there and talk to people. Normally we have to queue for hours or even days in front of the embassy to ask for visa. Now were invited and entered through the grand doors.</p>
<p><strong>A symbolic reversal.</strong></p>
<p>No, it’s a symbolic exception. If it had been a reversal, the whole Tunisian population would have been treated like that.</p>
<p><strong>On the blog “The Global Advocacy” by now famous blogger Sami Ben Gharbia there is an instruction of how to create a blog. It is written in the spirit that blogging can influence politics, can change things. On the other hand it seems a lot of people only blog for their own ego – and that pushes political issues to the back.</strong></p>
<p>Maybe this problem is typical Tunisian. Whenever we form a group or an association, it always turns into a cockfight and the interior fights of the group dominate over its objective. This creates a lot of problems. The media expected from every cyber dissident to create his own blog, the only way to exist afterwards. There are too many different egos and objectives – and blogging didn’t help us to unite or to feels part of the same movement. For many blogging is just a way to get access to the public.</p>
<p><strong>Tunisia is a country with very developed women’s rights and strong female voices. What role do they play within the bogging scene?</strong></p>
<p>There are of course also women who blog, I don’t know about their numbers. Many are very well known – unfortunately some just say what people in Europe want to hear – for example that mean Islamists are taking over the country.</p>
<p><strong>You mean for example the very popular blog Tunisian Girl by Lina Ben Mhenn…</strong></p>
<p>In a sense this is a problem that came with all this interest by the medias. It creates demands that get fulfilled.</p>
<p><strong>One of the demands of western media is to hear that there is an Islamic threat. But it is true: the Islamist party Ennahda won the first free elections in Tunisia.</strong></p>
<p>Yes. But they are not as bad, as people say, they are intelligent. We have to be aware how well they understood the system of the media. Every other week they push another topic, to occupy all heads and minds. The arabization of the school system was their first goal – and it worked, everybody got right into it. Nobody spoke of anything else. But that’s silly. They just do that to get the attention.</p>
<p><strong>They are populists.</strong></p>
<p>Yes, of course. It is understandable to fear Ennahda, but at a certain moment they will have to make a choice: modernity or orthodoxy. I am sure, they will chose modernity. They will let go of the baggage that they have carried for many years, the conservative radicals etc. But they still need them today because without the radicals, they wouldn’t have gotten 40% of the votes.<br />
We have to stop to get engaged in these silly debates over and over again. Why don’t we talk instead about unemployment – against which we demonstrated during the revolution. And about justice, about the reform of the Ministry of the Interior, the reform of the Ministry of Justice… Why don’t we speak about that? Because they keep us busy debating about the possibility of the sixth Khalifa. That’s silly. They are intelligent and they know very well how to use the situation.</p>
<p><strong>So you are optimistic about where this government will lead the country?</strong></p>
<p>I have nothing to do with this government. But if the majority of population votes for it, I am ready to approve even of this government, which doesn’t represent me. But I am still convinced that they will be replaced by another party that proposes better solutions.</p>
<p><strong>What do you think of the pirate parties all over the world – in Germany they are quite successful at the moment.</strong></p>
<p>I think they are a very good idea. Even in Tunisia, the idea of the pirates has contributed to the revolution. We had shops with pirated DVDs and software – so you could find software that is very expensive in Europe for very cheap. This helped in the revolution – if we would have had to pay for all the software we used, nobody would have been able to afford the cyber dissent. Piracy has helped to develop the whole process. Without it the cyber revolution wouldn’t have been possible.</p>
<p class="info"><strong>Sofiane Belhaj is a Tunisian activist known for his dissident role before the Tunisian revolution of 2010/11. 2008 he started his blog „I have a dream: a democratic Tunisia“ under the pseudonym Hamadi Kaloutcha. In late 2010 he translated American diplomatic cables regarding the Tunisian government released by WikiLeaks into French and Arabic. On January 6th, 2011 during the Tunisian revolution he got arrested and was released three days later. After the fall of Ben Ali, he was appointed to the Haute instance pour la réalisation des objectifs de la révolution, de la réforme politique et de la transition démocratique [Committee for the realisation of the principles of the Revolution, political reform and democratic transition].</strong></p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“We cannot be pessimistic”</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/we-cannot-be-pessimistic-2/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 06 Jan 2023 11:44:52 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1809</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[A conversation with the urbanists on the future of the movement and the relationship between media images of tents and the concrete outreach in all parts of society. New York, 6 November 2011 Today it has been fifty days since the beginning of Occupy Wall Street. The symbolic sign of the movement is Zuccotti Park [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A conversation with the urbanists on the future of the movement and the relationship between media images of tents and the concrete outreach in all parts of society.<br />
</strong><strong>New York, 6 November 2011</strong></p>
<p><strong>Today it has been fifty days since the beginning of Occupy Wall Street. The symbolic sign of the movement is Zuccotti Park with its iconic camp, its tents and signs, its self-organisation, and its visual presence in the media. But there are—less known but probably more important—a number of initiatives, committees, and sub-committees enlarging the idea, working out the demands, spreading it throughout the city. You are a member of the Education and Empowerment Committee. How would you describe the relationship between the very visible camp and the less visible activities backstage aiming for something more sustainable?</strong></p>
<p>All the committees that work alongside the movement started in the camp. In the beginning the movement was concentrated there and the camp played a very important role. But the question is, How necessary is the occupied space compared to all the other activities around Occupy Wall Street? What is their relationship? For example, all general assembly meetings happen in the camp. But if all of the more than 4,000 members were to attend, it would be impossible. The camp has logistically come to its limit. It is a representation of the movement. But it is not the movement itself.</p>
<p><strong>But it is still needed as an image?</strong></p>
<p>In the beginning it absolutely was. There have been many discussions about moving or leaving the camp. But such a decision has to be strategised very well. If we give it up, it should not be covered by the media as a defeat, as deserting. Why do we think about leaving the camp? Because we go beyond. Every day some of us occupy something. We go to the Ministry of Education, to the Ministry of Transportation, etc. And all of the important committee meetings happen at 60 Wall Street in a privately owned public lobby of a bank. The real actions of the movement are happening more and more outside the camp.</p>
<p><strong>But the camp also functions as a model of society—a self-made state. A lot of committees deal with its organisation: in the security council, former gang members and former cops discuss how to solve conflicts without violence, while psychology professors and students seek solutions for attending to mentally ill people who want to join the camp. You discuss how to distribute donated food, clothes, how to organise the camp’s library. It is like the creation of a social structure from scratch; it is negotiating how to live together—almost in a utopian way. </strong></p>
<p>The United States has a long history of homeless camps that started in the 1960s and 1970s. Recently, we may recall images from cities like Camden in New Jersey or the outskirts of Newark or the North of Philadelphia or certain areas of Detroit where there are campsites of homeless people. They are called “tent cities”. Historically, tent cities have been associated with radical social formations. Homeless get organised and create their own environment and start to demand or construct or resist certain issues. They get empowered not only by themselves but also by organisations who give them the tents or food, etc. Don Mitchell says in his book The Right to the City that the reason why tent cities haven’t proliferated is that the government has always tried to annihilate them. The moment they start creating some sort of social cohesion, they get dissolved. The government is afraid of this form of organisation.</p>
<p>I think that the camp here mimics this. Don Mitchell argues that tent cities are centres for radicalisation. There has been an incredible knowledge transfer from homelessness into the camp, how to retain, how to survive. In the camp here there are some homeless, too. And many of the people that now give advice, for example on how to survive in the cold, are actually homeless. So, the camp might have its own very-well-working organisation, enclave-like community, where people form their own society, their own medical aid, etc.</p>
<p>It is a site of experimentation, of resistance, and of representation of the resistance. It might be a prototypical city, but we cannot forget what this movement is about. It’s about all of us. The people in the camp, they are the 99 per cent, but only together with the people who live around them in the same city, in the same world order.</p>
<p><strong>It seems like the 99 per cent still need the image of the camp. What will happen when it is gone?</strong></p>
<p>The image of the camp is very powerful. But the biggest efforts of the education committee or the outreach committee are about going into the disempowered neighbourhoods of New York and being present there. There is only a certain type of people who approach Zuccotti Park, which in the end is very limited. We have to reach out to those that have no access to Zuccotti Park. When we talk about the representation of the 99 per cent, we still have taxi drivers, we have room servers, we have construction workers from the MTA; we have steel workers around or cleaners or waitresses. And I don’t think that the Zuccotti camp does enough. The possibility to create different campsites all over the city is much more powerful than one central location in the city as a representation. I am more worried about how we can attract taxi drivers, sweepers of the park, gardeners—all those who’ve been much more oppressed than a big number of the people represented in Zuccotti Park.</p>
<p><strong>So, what should the next steps be? How should the movement develop?</strong></p>
<p>Look at the newspapers this week. Every single one claims that the G20 was a complete failure. Greece is totally in the mode chaos. Spain is getting there. Italy is in a very bad situation. France is also facing the threat of economical problems. There will be a tremendous growth of the movement all over the world. I think the movement should open its arms as wide as possible. To unite the Indignados, or ¡Democracia real YA!, or Krytyka Polityczna and so on, and to create a hyper-coalition of all of us. So, I believe that the movement will spread out. The movement grows organically; it’s already everywhere. The most important thing is, again, to go as a movement to the working class. We have to be in the disempowered neighbourhoods. The movement cannot be focused on those people who are already disappointed by the dominant politics and economy. Those people are at Zuccotti Park now. But there are people who are oppressed and who cannot imagine that something can change—they are in fact the majority. We have to approach them and integrate them; we have to listen to them and convince them to join.</p>
<p><strong>If we compare the rather small number of Occupy Wall Street members with the huge movements in Spain or Greece, we realise that it’s not the number that makes media interested in your activity. Why are journalists so strongly focused on Occupy Wall Street? </strong></p>
<p>Because Americans have been sleeping for decades. But that’s the end of this inertia. In the U.S. we are in the “belly of the beast”—in New York we are in the financial capital of the empire. And if the very centre of the empire is infected by the resistance movement, it can happen anywhere.</p>
<p><strong>The movement has no leaders. At the same time you have more than eighty working groups targeting particular issues. What do they produce? What are your demands?</strong></p>
<p>If we were to issue demands, we would be immediately co-opted and we would lose independence. The majority of us feel the same. Nobody wants to demand anything. We are totally disillusioned with the political system. The radicalism of the different manifestations around the world in the last two years has not been based on demanding anything from the government. They have been focused on self-awareness of society, on self-governing, without relying on politics.</p>
<p><strong>In the beginning pure resistance might be good. But at a certain point you have to act, not only react. You cannot stay only extra-parliamentary.</strong></p>
<p>Calm down. The movement is very young and it needs to form itself. The movement has transformed us and given us the possibility of creating parallel political, social, and economical realities. Perhaps in developing this parallel world, we will be able to insert ourselves into the political apparatus of the country one day. The democracy in America is not like the German one, where such a group like the Piratenpartei can suddenly appear, receive 10 per cent of the votes, and become a part of the governmental system. Here we have a two-party mob which controls everything through the financial system and blocks all ways to the Congress for all political subjects who are not Democrats or Republicans.</p>
<p><strong>Already now, after six or seven weeks, it seems that different interests are tearing at this movement from all sides. Some want to either co-opt it, buy it, promote it, or kill it. How can you resist these demands? Are you not afraid of being transformed by the dominant system in order to mimic it?</strong></p>
<p>People compare Occupy Wall Street to 1968. They remember May ‘68 because that’s when the riots happened. But 1968 lasted approximately three years. During this time they changed a lot, but later the process was stopped. Today we are fighting with a much bigger creature than in 1968. The globe is totally centralised now. Controlling and handling 40 per cent of the wealth of the world are 147 corporations. The internal economies of different states are strongly interconnected. Now, the EU is a completely different animal than it was in 1968. So patience will be one of our commandments. If we keep the same direction with the same principles, remain engaged and slowly grow, then capitalism will bring us more and more people, because this system is not able to change its own logic. Again and again capitalism makes people disappointed.</p>
<p>Occupy Wall Street has a structure. All of its committees—economy, education, media and so on—already have projects which are really developed. They will hopefully emerge in one year. We are able to create a nomadic university, alternative media and so on. We are practicing alternative politics and alternative economy. So, let’s continue.</p>
<p><strong>Aren’t you afraid that this enthusiasm will wear off?</strong></p>
<p>We cannot be pessimistic. For the first time, we feel that we are pre-something, not post-something. But it’s very difficult to predict what’s coming. The big questions is—and I’m quoting a song from Laurie Anderson—“How do we begin again?” Finally we are in the beginning of a brand new era. But which way do we go? We should figure this out before the movement gets hijacked by the financiers, by the capital market, by the governors, by a cynical political class. We have very few chances of doing something as a society, of making a revolution. If this movement dies, we are all damned. We cannot lose enthusiasm, because it will be very difficult to pick up similar feelings again. It is not a revolution in the traditional sense, where a new structure of power replaces the old one. This is a slow process of developing a parallel society which is free from capitalism, which is free from cynical exclusive politics.</p>
<p><strong>What concrete steps should be taken? </strong></p>
<p>In Amsterdam, at the Congress of Social Housing, there was a Dutch politician who proposed to develop houses for members of wide class spectrum, from high to low income, in the same neighbourhood, built by citizens. The programme pays an architect to design the house, and you can apply for funds to build your house. That’s a very small reform. But we should be focused on such strategies of self-governing and self-representation. As long as we don’t destroy the mortgage system that was imposed on citizens in the early 1990s by the neo-liberal governments, we are not changing anything. It’s a very Marxist structuralist understanding of the world, but that’s the way we see it. We know that we cannot destroy capitalism, even if thousands of bank accounts were closed during the last month. Our program “take your money out of the bank” is very effective and very concrete. It is so effective that the Bank of America retreated from its fees for cash withdrawal. That’s the evidence that we have an impact. But we must remember that the biggest amount of money that bankers are using doesn’t come from us. It comes from the financial system. Through coordinated people’s actions we can hurt them, but not seriously. So, the structural change is much more fundamental. There are alternative forms of banking and health systems, which are not related to the market. If we could build it at a macro scale, it would be a fundamental change.</p>
<p><strong>We consider ourselves to be conscious entities, but we actually have no control over this economic knowledge. </strong></p>
<p>That’s true. Following Marx, the movement is developing a class-consciousness now. Reading his writings is really canny. Now we are pushing for the New School to get out of the Bank of America. The whole faculty is pushing for that. Isn’t it great?</p>
<p><strong>The public space that is occupied here, Zuccotti Park or 60 Wall Street, is in fact privately owned. You have spent the last fifteen years fighting against such ownership. Now it’s the only space in the downtown area where police cannot easily enter. The privatised “public” space seems to be more public than the real public space. </strong></p>
<p>It’s a fantastic paradox. When there are actions on Washington Square, the police evicts the participants immediately because it’s real public space. But private space can be easily used against private interests. Our working groups can sit there and think how to radically redefine the meaning of the word “private property”.</p>
<p><strong>The situation of Occupy Wall Street has drastically changed, and the city removed the camp during the last month. There has also been less and less interest displayed by the media for the movement. Where does Occupy Wall Street stand now? </strong></p>
<p>True, but I am certain that the eviction has benefited the movement and its strategic outreach. For the majority of us, the movement’s success has been its consolidation around operative taskforces and working-groups which continue their short- and long-term projects and local and international outreach. I believe the movement today is much more consolidated and mature, with more defined targets, concepts, and active members. We are definitely moving away from the spectacle and have begun to be focused on the underpowered neighbourhoods and peripheral urgencies that need our support. Occupy Wall Street has already drastically changed the USA itself. It has produced an unprecedented awareness, contributed to pedagogical discourse, and has brought recognition and solidarity among the millions of citizens that have had enough!</p>
<p>According to the media, contrary to the sensationalistic coverage Occupy Wall Street got in the first month of its activity, every coordinated mass action we have organised has been given serious coverage in the international and national press. To give you an example, last Tuesday I participated in the national day of action on housing and foreclosures; the next day, The Guardian had a video report of the action on its front news page. The press has matured together with us, and this is a great thing.</p>
<p><strong>Your optimism abounds.</strong></p>
<p>My trust in the movement and the quality of people engaged in it is greater than ever. We are ever more aware that a revolution is never instant; it is a slow process that requires a lot of energy and dedication, and it feels like all of us working in it have decided to stay and continue the struggle.</p>
<p><strong>Christmas and New Year’s are coming up as is a cold New York winter. Will there still be a relevant movement next spring?</strong></p>
<p>Absolutely! The Occupy Wall Street calendar is full of actions, from the three-month anniversary of national action on 17 December, to the occupation of the Department of Education and the Department of Buildings later in the month, and in January the Occupation of the US Congress, and so many projects that are in their early stages. The movement continues to gain energy. The difference is that the spectacle has been reduced to a minimum, and now we just have hard work to do.</p>
<p><strong>What is the future of Occupy Wall Street?</strong></p>
<p>We will continue our outreach in underpowered communities and develop taskforces with them. We will put into operation many projects like the Occupy Wall Street Nomadic University, extended open forums, student debt assistance, a foreclosure taskforce, a health-care system free from the market, housing alternatives and so on. And of course, more occupations!</p>
<p>Next year the struggle will continue! The time has come to redefine ourselves inside the active dimensions of the urban movements: 15-M, Occupy Wall Street, Indignados, The Arab Spring, ¡Democracia real YA! All of us are working on structural change in reality. It’s not about urban development, art, geography, sociology, political science, architecture, politics, health care and so on. We must struggle collectively to destroy our centuries-old disciplinary silos, to merge all separated disciplines into the dynamic ecological totality of civic action, into our precarious daily lives. Then, I believe, we might be able to conceive a new direction, together. You have my hand, how do we begin again?</p>
<p class="info"><strong>Gabriela Rendón is an architect and urbanist. Her work combines research, planning and design at different scales focusing on spatial processes and transformations counteracting conditions produced by market-oriented urbanization. Rendon’s areas of expertise include housing and urban policy analysis and development, neighborhood decline and restructuring, and community-based planning. Her current research is based on the politics, practices and constrains of socio-spatial restructuring through citizens active engagement in low-income neighborhoods in Western Europe and America. Gabriela Rendon is co-founder of Cohabitation Strategies, researcher at Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands, where she has coordinated and instructed architectural and urban design studios collaborating with activist, non-profit organizations, and grassroots groups.</strong></p>
<p class="info"><strong>Miguel Robles-Durán, urbanist, is co-founder of “Cohabitation Strategies”, Director of the Urban Ecologies graduate program at the New School/Parsons in New York and Senior fellow at &#8222;Civic City&#8220;, a post-graduate design/research program based in HEAD Geneva, Switzerland. Robles-Durán has wide international experience in the strategic definition/coordination of trans-disciplinary urban projects, as well as in the development tactical design strategies and civic engagement platforms that confront the contradictions of contemporary urbanization. He recently co-edited/authored the book &#8222;Urban Asymmetries: Studies and Projects on Neoliberal Urbanization&#8220; that reviews the dire consequences that neoliberal urban policies have had upon the city and discusses possible alternatives to market-driven development. Robles-Durán’s areas of specialization are design/research interventions and strategies in uneven urbanization and areas of social urban conflict, urban political-economy and urban theory.</strong></p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“Occupy a museum near you”</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/occupy-a-museum-near-you/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 06 Jan 2023 11:24:30 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/occupy-a-museum-near-you/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[New York, 6 NOV 2011 You are the initiator of the Occupy Museums group, associated with Occupy Wall Street. First you organised a protest march to MoMA, and later you occupied the New Museum and other art institutions run by, as you say, the 1%”. When the directors of MoMA asked what you wanted, you [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>New York, 6 NOV 2011</strong></p>
<p><strong>You are the initiator of the Occupy Museums group, associated with Occupy Wall Street. First you organised a protest march to MoMA, and later you occupied the New Museum and other art institutions run by, as you say, the 1%”. When the directors of MoMA asked what you wanted, you replied that you had no demands. “But,” you said, “we would continue to occupy the Museum in order to open up a conversation about economic injustice and abuse of the public values for the gain of the 1% in the art world.”</strong></p>
<p>Occupy Museums is a collective, which runs by consensus. I initiated the first Occupy Museums action in October 2011. Every action and official text we create is authored by all of us, and we don’t have a single leader. Functioning in solidarity is the spirit of the Occupy Wall Street movement. We are trying to forget about the drive toward individualism and hierarchy, which is so much a part of the capitalistic regime. We also believe in individual autonomy. So first I want to make it clear that these are my own opinions; I can’t speak for the whole Occupy Museums group.</p>
<p>So, why do we Occupy Museums? Today museums are an important part of the neo-liberal system, which we are protesting on Wall Street. Museums are like temples of this system, actually; they reproduce the logic of the system, reify its symbols, and are financially dependent on it. Actions by Occupy Museums are about opening up a very large, honest, transformative conversation about the presence of money and power in the world of art and culture.</p>
<p><strong>As much power as museums have in creating symbolic value – galleries would be the ones more directly involved in creating monetary value.</strong></p>
<p>But museums hold cultural authority and carry out a supposedly purely public function that galleries and art fairs do not have. Currently, the main art-world paradigm in the US is a private market of artists that are represented by a hierarchy of galleries, and these galleries want to get their artists into the Whitney Biennial or the New Museum or, eventually, into the Museum of Modern Art. Therefore, an artist’s career and markets are built up through the cultural authority of the museums. Nothing else counts but your symbolic and financial position, and museums have the power to shape this. The problem is that, just like on Wall Street, the wealthiest 1% control nearly everything. They engage in philanthropy, of course, and sit on museum boards, and these are often also the mega-collectors who influence the markets. Actually, the whole arts infrastructure has been organising around these few individuals in the last thirty years. They concentrate political power and social prestige in their hands, perhaps even more than money, if this is possible. But real, essential culture needs distance from this power and influence in order to grow and thrive, otherwise culture becomes a luxury commodity. What will hopefully come out of the Occupy Museums is a re-thinking about the current state of culture, which is very close to a luxury item for the wealthiest. How can we reconnect our work as artists to the experience of ordinary people—the 99%? We have already found a way to connect as artists to the spirit of protest in the air. For the first stage we are publicly defining cultural injustices—inviting people to call them out in open assemblies at the museums. A lot of information about the corruption and conflicts of interest on museum boards arises from the participants in these assemblies. But maybe the most important thing Occupy Museums is doing is publically demonstrating, through solidarity, that we artists need not be silenced by these powerful institutions that wield so much cultural authority, just because the 1% sits on their boards. We are learning not to fear, but to act.</p>
<p><strong>The first museums you went to a MoMA and the National History Museum. Why these two?</strong></p>
<p>MoMA is an iconic New York museum, because it is “the one and only” Museum of Modern Art. And New York is a city that is supposed to have made its name on the international stage through modern art. MoMA, therefore, is very much a temple, a holy space where the local gods such as Pollock and Newman dwell. It is also transparently financially corrupted. Two MoMA trustees, James Niven and Richard Oldenberg, also have connections to the board of Sotheby’s. These trustees help to inflate prices in the art auctions, and they presumably have some vote or influence about what is shown in the museum. This simultaneous conflict of interest should be unacceptable and considered as abuse, but in the US now, it’s become accepted—we also see it in the revolving door between the US government and the biggest corporations such as banks. But people would be surprised to find these problems associated with museums, even though the art market is extremely unregulated. And it is precisely because MoMA is iconic and also beloved and trusted by many that Occupy Museums decided to go after it and make it into an example. We are going straight to the top, “storming the temple”. In fact, we do not really occupy physical places—we rather occupy people’s consciousness, symbols.</p>
<p><strong>But the Natural History museum is not especially related to art.</strong></p>
<p>Here we focused on the potential menace of philanthropy. We occupied the Dinosaur wing in the American Museum of Natural History, whose patron, David H. Koch, is the second richest person in New York and a major funder of the ultra right-wing in the US. For this action, we were talking to visitors at the Museum about the ideology associated with his “gifts”. David H. Koch has been the primary funder of the Tea Party, right-wing think tanks, and numerous initiatives which try to negate global warming. Often he has censored climate information in the exhibitions that he sponsors. His father, who built the family fortune, was also a right-wing ideologue in the McCarthy era who used the threat of communism to create a political platform full of racism and bigotry—this is actually the pre-history of the Tea Party. We also discussed how the funding of culture is often used to clean the image of those that make dirty money (Koch makes his money from the oil and energy business, and his companies are known for polluting). At the Museum of Natural History, we created a series of performances followed by a discussion of what alternative models of philanthropy might look like, such as more government support or support from many smaller contributions. Obviously, we are just beginning this discussion.</p>
<p><strong>When the director of MoMA came to talk, you refused. Why? Aren’t you interested in a productive dialog?</strong></p>
<p>For the first action, we held a General Assembly meeting in front of MoMA and read a manifesto, and then the director and a couple other staff members came down to meet us. They were very nice and said that they support the movement to some extent and asked why we were there. I answered very much in line with the manifesto, that we believe that MoMA is the temple of the 1%, and our aim is to challenge this concentration of power and wealth, which is crippling our culture and futures as artists. They were surprised and asked for our demands. I said we have no demands, but we are going to continue occupying their museum, which in this case means repeatedly coming back and enlarging the conversation until it is much more visible and spread out. Actually, for a long time, the press kept asking for demands of the Occupy Wall Street movement. So far it has been very helpful for the movement to not have demands. As soon as you have demands, you’re asking those with power to change something finite (a few things), when many feel that the problem is structural. Without demands, we focus more on developing our voice autonomously and building our movement’s solidarity, which is the base of our power. The problems of economic injustice are so big that starting out in a negotiation mode does not make sense.</p>
<p><strong>Later on you  also did an action at Lincoln Center in New York…</strong></p>
<p>That was our most triumphant action of 2011! The Lincoln Center, supported by David H. Koch and New York’s mayor Michael Bloomberg, is a potent symbol of the privatisation of public space and an abuse of cultural authority. As we stated in the press release for the action, “it is no doubt a coincidence that Philip Glass’ opera ‘Satyagraha’, which depicts Gandhi’s early struggle against colonial oppression in India, was revived in the revolutionary 2011. We immediately saw a glaring contradiction in ‘Satyagraha’ being performed while in recent weeks protestors from Occupy Wall Street have been arrested. The juxtaposition was stark. While Bloomberg funds the representation of Gandhi’s pioneering tactics of nonviolent civil disobedience in the Metropolitan Opera House, he simultaneously orders a paramilitary-style raid on the peaceful public occupation of Liberty Park, where protestors are beaten, tear-gassed, and violently arrested.” So, one evening, hundreds of protesters assembled on the steps of Lincoln Center, blocked off from the plaza by police barricades. A few who dared to cross the line were arrested, provoking shouts of “shame, shame, shame!” We took off our shoes—a Gandhian symbol of dignity—and stood barefoot on the cold pavement, conducting our assembly. When the opera ended and the opera audience exited into the plaza, they came upon this strikingly theatrical scene—real, live, non-violent protest, barefoot on the grand steps! Some protesters were chanting “We are the 99%”, which may have contributed to a sense of separation between these two parallel crowds. Our presence behind the police barricades somehow paralysed the opera audience, making them hesitant to flow toward us, even as we called them to join. Then all of a sudden Philip Glass popped up in the Occupy Wall Street crowd—he had come to read a statement using the “people’s microphone”. He called out the last lines of the opera, a passage from the “Bhagavad Gita”:</p>
<blockquote><p><strong>When righteousness withers away / And evil rules the land / We come into being / Age after age / And take visible shape / And move / A man among men / For the protection of good / Thrusting back evil / And setting virtue / On her seat again.</strong></p></blockquote>
<p>In that moment the opera audience had joined us. The buffer zone was gone. We were now one big crowd. Until late into the night we held our general assembly and many people spoke—opera singers who had been recently fired by Lincoln Center in its neo-liberal war against workers, and also Lou Reed was there and expressed his support.</p>
<p><strong>Occupying Museums is very careful of not being co-opted by any institution. You refuse any collaboration, even if this is how you could reach out.</strong></p>
<p>Since the beginning of Occupy Wall Street, co-option has been a major concern, because neo-liberal capitalism knows very well that the best way to kill protest movements is to absorb them into the existing market and to dissolve them or use them for advertising purposes. If we started to negotiate with MoMA, they might say, “You may use the first floor for a special General Assembly, we’ll put in on the website.” In this way, they might try to throw us a bone before they deal with critique we raise. And then while negotiating, we might have our ego pumped and feel special because these famous gatekeeping institutions have opened their gates for us just a little.</p>
<p>It is of course not so black and white because many people who are in the movement work for art institutions; some are even powerful curators, critics, and well-known artists. We of course also need to find allies to change structures of the institutions from the inside. The question is how to proceed in this while keeping our clarity of critique?</p>
<p>I feel that before we join the people who run the museums, we should join in solidarity with the wider communities of New York City—artists and art lovers who are not so privileged. New York City is one of the richest and the most class-divided cities in the world. It has not much of a middle class, but a lot of very wealthy and a lot of very poor people. It also has many extremely rich artists and a vast number of poor artists. Those are the economic and racial barriers, which have been built up for generations, that we have to break. We must bring together wider communities that usually do not hang out together in the art world, and change the class and race segregation that we see in culture, even if this takes lots of work and lots of time.</p>
<p><strong>So, if you were the director of MoMA what would you do in these circumstances?</strong></p>
<p>It would be cool for the MoMA director to join us in an open conversation with our group. Curators at MoMA are used to having their asses kissed by artists, but maybe they would be interested in a new dynamic where everyone is equal, where people are focused on justice and mass consciousness rather than just on individual competitive gain? They could join the discussion, because then we could find out—outside the power relations—what they think as individuals. Many people want to see big changes in our world—I’m sure some museum directors do, too. We all need to get started, so they could begin by meeting us if they want. There is nothing stopping them—our group is open.</p>
<p><strong>So what would institutions to do in order to join you?</strong></p>
<p>You have to be ready to step into the mud. You have to be ready for a long, uncomfortable conversation. Our movement calls to question the structure of the museum boards and the flow of capital itself within culture. It calls on everyone to study their own privilege and work together to change a world that is so divided by access to money and power. We have to unlearn lots of capitalist conditioning to be able to work together. We have to spend a really long time with these conversations, be ready to fail, stay away from the easy traps of market-friendly shows and celebrity artists that we think everyone wants. We need to practice transparency and fairness in our working process. We should be aware that power and hierarchy are always to be found in human society. We have to challenge it. If we do not experiment and get messy, we cannot start finding answers. We cannot make demands right now—we need to change our minds first, then we can create a parallel economy with freedom rather than oppression as a basis.</p>
<p><strong>Forty years ago the Art Workers’ Coalition, an association of artists, filmmakers, writers, critics, and museum personnel successfully put pressure on New York City’s museums—notably the Museum of Modern Art—to implement various reforms. They for instance sought a less exclusive exhibition policy, one that should include women artists and artists of colour, and they emphasised the importance of taking a moral stance on the Vietnam War. Moreover, the coalition prevailed on MoMA and other museums to implement a free-admission day that still exists in many institutions. Is it an inspiration?</strong></p>
<p>Yes, and there are other good examples of artists in this tradition, like the Russian Constructivists, the Mexican Muralists, Act Up, and so on. But the Art Workers’ Coalition is very important. In fact, we recently re-occupied MoMA on one of the free nights which are called “Target Free Fridays”. Target is a large US retailing corporation, and everyone thinks that this company invented the idea of free museum days. One goal for this action was to let people know that artists (Art Workers’ Coalition) invented it, that there is a history of artists standing up for the 99%; and another was to stand in solidarity with a group of union workers.</p>
<p>There is an art handlers’ union, which works for Sotheby’s auction house. Sotheby’s was trying to take away their health-care and cut their pay, and when they tried to negotiate, Sotheby’s locked them out of work. So, since MoMA has a close relationship with Sotheby’s, we occupied MoMA to put some pressure on the board members to support the workers. We held a general assembly in front of Diego Rivera’s show and read a revolutionary text signed by Rivera and André Breton in 1938. We held an assembly with hundreds of artists in the main atrium of MoMA where a huge banner was displayed that stated “When Art Is Just a Luxury, Art Is a Lie!” This time, MoMA left us alone. I think that kicking out a bunch of artist activists on a free night initiated by artist activists (Art Workers’ Coalition) would have been a public relations disaster for the museum. For a couple of hours, we transformed MoMA into a forum for active discussion about money and labour in the art world.</p>
<p>There are concrete issues to be achieved: museums and the whole world of culture could pay artists for their labour; they could also pay the workers in the museums much better salaries. More artists could be included in an egalitarian market and earn money out of their artistic profession. We could regulate the extremely speculative art market, which helps only a handful of people—the millionaire artists and billionaire collectors. Unfortunately museums have fallen into a free-market ideology, which doesn’t recognise the importance of fairly compensating people’s labour and believes in speculation as a saviour.</p>
<p><strong>Do you have the impression that something is changing?</strong></p>
<p>The first step is simply to start coming together and talking. We need to realise that it is going to be messy for a while. Initially, many newspapers and blogs scoffed at the Occupy Museums protest, but recently that tendency started to change. There were articles in The New York Times that talk about the money laundering of Ronald Lauder and his Neue Galerie, or about the Guggenheim’s abuse of labour in the Middle East. There were articles in The Huffington Post about art funds for museums that disproportionately assist wealthy white audiences.<br />
We have to wake up and remember that art is everyone’s inheritance. Big art fairs like Art Basel and the Armory Show have direct connections to New York’s museums. That’s a place for the wealthiest people in the world to shop. There are 100,000 artists in New York City, but museums show the same people that are highlighted in art fairs and feed the cult of art celebrities. With Occupy Museums, we are taking the first steps toward a future where our cultural commons are truly shared and celebrated, not hoarded by the few. Occupy a museum near you.</p>
<p class="info"><strong>Noah Fischer is a Brooklyn-based artist and activist. He has also worked collaboratively with the Berlin-based performance group andcompany&amp;Co on numerous projects.  In 2008 Fischer began a transition from “private” projects free public collaborations. This journey led to the Summer of Change: a series of numismatic rituals performed on Wall Street with the Aaron Burr Society in Summer 2011. On September 17th, 2011, Fischer joined Occupy Wall Street on its first day, donning a large silver Dime mask. Noah initiated Occupy Subways and Occupy Museums in the first weeks of OWS and currently spends much of his time working with the Occupying Museums collective . Noah is the curator of the No-Eyes Viewing Wall at Brooklyn Zen Center.</strong></p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>The Scripted Realities of Rimini Protokoll</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/the-scripted-realities-of-rimini-protokoll/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 25 Dec 2022 10:54:25 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/the-scripted-realities-of-rimini-protokoll/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Four women in their eighties, with their old voices and old bodies, pose as race-car drivers with signal flags, a stair lift, and zimmer frames for orientation. Speed, the proximity of death and the merging of bodies and technology are important themes in homes for the elderly as well as in Rimini Protokoll’s Kreuzworträtsel Boxenstopp [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Four women in their eighties, with their old voices and old bodies, pose as race-car drivers with signal flags, a stair lift, and zimmer frames for orientation. Speed, the proximity of death and the merging of bodies and technology are important themes in homes for the elderly as well as in Rimini Protokoll’s <em>Kreuzworträtsel Boxenstopp</em> (<em>Crossword Pit Stop</em>, 2000) with its fictional staging of “Formula 1” race resulting in astonishingly perceptive narratives about life at the end of life.</p>
<p>Rimini Protokoll is, in varying configurations, a company of three freelance directors, Helgard Haug, Stefan Kaegi and Daniel Wetzel, who without using actors or existing texts produce work on  major stages in important cities such as Hamburg, Vienna, Düsseldorf and Zurich. Since <em>Kreuzworträtsel Boxenstopp</em> the work of Haug, Kaegi and Wetzel has become unusually successful for a theatre group that does not work with actors, does not stage dramatic texts and does not fulfil the requirements of repertory theatre as it dominates German and most European stages. The members of Rimini Protokoll have been invited to the Berliner Theatertreffen twice (where theatre not created from dramatic texts is rarely represented) and recently were awarded the Mülheimer Dramatikerpreis and the Europe Prize for New Theatrical Realities. Tours of their new productions typically take place throughout Europe as well as in South America and India.</p>
<p>The reason for Rimini Protokoll’s success is in its presentation of a complex world in which the individual is fundamental and the truth is always a narrative. The company has hit a nerve amongst, somewhat exceptionally, theatre practitioners, critics and audiences alike, with theatre that is documentary in the sense of relating directly to the world as we experience it, an experience that often seems to evade our grasp. War, global market economy, capitalism, unemployment, old age, dying, and death all are Rimini Protokoll&#8217;s themes. They stake a claim for the particular, concrete person and against the politically generalized. Their version of documentary is one in which the very notion of documentary is juxtaposed with subjective experiences in which the individual and the social  are combined in a way that expands subjective perception.  While clear-cut theses, messages and opinions are avoided, Haug, Kaegi and Wetzel make, to loosely quote Godard, theatre political rather than political theatre.</p>
<p>Kreuzworträtsel Boxenstopp was the first collaborative work by Haug, Kaegi and Wetzel, three former students of the Institute of Applied Theatre Studies in Gießen/Germany. The premiere in November 2000 (before they had even given themselves the name Rimini Protokoll) exhibited almost all of the characteristics that have so unmistakably informed all their subsequent work. These characteristics include using non-professional performers as experts of both their own lives and of the everyday; the examination of the actual performance space and its surroundings (in the case of <em>Kreuzworträtsel Boxenstopp</em>, an old people’s home next door to the theatre); a text that is simultaneously documentary and literary and blends disparate research material (like old age and the staging of a fiction such as the “Formula 1” race) and bears clear traces of its own production; and, a dramaturgy that, like the text, developed from the material it discovered and  that always simultaneously protects and challenges the performers. Kreuzworträtsel Boxenstopp was in many respects not only the prototype for a number of major stage productions that followed, but also the starting point for site-specific projects, radio plays, audio installations, small documentaries and short profiles.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Unrest and Discontent. Political Theatre and the Agonistic Field</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/unrest-and-discontent-political-theatre-and-the-agonistic-field/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 25 Dec 2022 10:46:25 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1754</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[The more the time we are living through seems out of joint, the harder it has been for the theatre, which in the past was often looked upon as „the“ political art, to find its footing. Either theatre doubts its own social relevance, or it delegates this relevance to specific political, but not necessarily artistic, [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The more the time we are living through seems out of joint, the harder it has been for the theatre, which in the past was often looked upon as „the“ political art, to find its footing.</strong></p>
<p>Either theatre doubts its own social relevance, or it delegates this relevance to specific political, but not necessarily artistic, action. Or then again it resorts to old aesthetic devices that are essentially restricted to frontal, critical presentations of grievances, but finds no proper (that is, itself political) form for this strategy.</p>
<p>Yet there exists again, after a period of mainly narrative theatre in the 1970s and 80s, followed by post-dramatic forms that focused on the medium and its aesthetics themselves, a strong desire for political theatre. A theatre that finds not only access to important social issues, but is itself a political space and public sphere. Yet there is no longer a common short organum for the theatre (Bertolt Brecht, 1948) that we could follow. We find ourselves in a period of experimentation, of searching – on the part of both artists and audience. There are, however, plenty of artistic approaches that make clear again the potential of political theatre.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>What Role Can Art Play in Politics</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/what-role-can-art-play-in-politics/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 25 Dec 2022 10:41:10 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/what-role-can-art-play-in-politics/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Suddenly there is this persistent call for an art that is useful, for direct commitment, for artistic activism, for intervention in the political reality of our society and economy. And it is good so. Of course it is a provocation: after hundreds of years of fighting for the autonomy of art, after decades of learning [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Suddenly there is this persistent call for an art that is useful, for direct commitment, for artistic activism, for intervention in the political reality of our society and economy. And it is good so.</strong></p>
<p>Of course it is a provocation: after hundreds of years of fighting for the autonomy of art, after decades of learning that the essential quality of art is ambiguity, after years of repeating that art poses rather than answers questions, there is suddenly this persistent call for an art that is useful, for direct commitment, for artistic activism, for intervention in the political reality of our society and economy.</p>
<p>This call is not new; it has precursors – the Productivists, for example. Contradicting Naum Gabo’s stipulation that Constructivism in post-revolutionary Russia should be committed exclusively to abstraction, artists such as Aleksei Gan, Alexander Rodchenko und Varvara Stepanova demanded a practical, socially useful role for art. In 1973, some fifty years later, Joseph Beuys opened his Free International University (FIU) and proclaimed: “To be a teacher is my greatest artwork”.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Dramaturgies of Generosity. The Theatre of BADco.</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/dramaturgies-of-generosity-the-theatre-of-badco/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 24 Dec 2022 11:40:36 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1713</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[In the middle of a rather crowded space, on a stage cut off from the auditorium by the iron curtain. Squeezed in between others at a table, no way to see everything, always having to turn your neck to look at the other full tables, at the door on the opposite side where some kind [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the middle of a rather crowded space, on a stage cut off from the auditorium by the iron curtain. Squeezed in between others at a table, no way to see everything, always having to turn your neck to look at the other full tables, at the door on the opposite side where some kind of film noir action seems to be taking place, or at the small strip in front of a wall, which serves as a wide screen stage for dancing and cursing and projecting. Voices from radios, and voices from performers at the tables, almost whispering as if not to disturb anyone, barely audible across the tables, accompanied by some photocopies, but there is no time to really read or even understand them. Memories are Made of This&#8230; performance notes, the title of this work by BADco. from 2006, quotes a Dean Martin song, but for the moment it is uncertain if it is not the other way around: We are in the middle of a memory machine – but does it produce memories or is it fuelled by them? What then does it produce? More memories? As with the famous <em>Wunderblock</em> – a waxed blackboard for children to write on, used by Freud as a metaphor for human memory – you can no longer really decipher what is beneath the permanently re-written first layer. But you also cannot ignore it.</p>
<p><strong>Too much</strong></p>
<p>There are at least two kinds of too much. One that annoys by exaggeration, that frustrates because you are never able to cope, that feeds you until you cannot swallow any more. Too much of ‘anything goes’, too much gluttony and mindless consumption. And there is too much as a thoughtful offer of possibilities. Not just accumulation but too much that offers choices, that empowers, that frees even when it is overwhelming. Too much that opens a field of thinking, associating, experiencing. Too much that takes its opposite seriously. Too much as a gesture of invitation and generosity.</p>
<p><strong>Tasks for guests and hosts</strong></p>
<p>It is this gesture of sometimes overburdening generosity that characterises many of BADco.’s recent performances. And even though this attitude can be read as the continuation of a specific modernist theatre tradition aiming to lay out a wide semiotic field by producing an excess of signifiers, this is not the full truth. While the work of their predecessors (most famously the New York neo-avant-garde antagonists the Wooster group and Richard Foreman, or in Europe – even though very different in style – the young Jan Fabre, Heiner Müller or Romeo Castellucci, to name a few) has its roots very much in an urge to liberate theatre from the primacy of text, from limitations by causal, linear narrations, by psychology, etc., BADco. takes it for granted that this prominent fight from the 1980s and early 1990s was won long ago. Not only do they use the booty of these struggles in whatever way they need to – they also add to it the attainments of the parallel, often ignored story of the arts and theatre in (South-) East Europe, and especially the former Yugoslavia.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>&#8222;You can be a virtuoso at being sloppy”</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/you-can-be-a-virtuoso-at-being-sloppy/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 23 Dec 2022 14:28:18 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/you-can-be-a-virtuoso-at-being-sloppy/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher: Virtuosity is the concept we investigate from different angles in this year’s edition of steirischer herbst. When I look for a positive connotation of that term, you are one of the artists that first come to my mind. Do you feel comfortable with this rather old-fashioned term, is it still valuable? Or is [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Florian Malzacher: Virtuosity is the concept we investigate from different angles in this year’s edition of steirischer herbst. When I look for a positive connotation of that term, you are one of the artists that first come to my mind. Do you feel comfortable with this rather old-fashioned term, is it still valuable? Or is virtuosity just something to hate as a distraction from more important layers of art?</strong></p>
<p>William Forsythe: Oh, I think it is a bit like hating your parents: It became trendy. But virtuosity is simply a word that was chosen to describe a certain phenomenon – and to ascribe to a word a kind of ubiquitous power over the structure of art is really preposterous. There is no way to determine what conditions art can emerge in. And you can be a virtuoso at being sloppy – I mean: in a good way. You can decide: I need to be really sloppy in this scene, I am going to be the incarnation of sloppiness. Then you could be a virtuoso in that. It is just a word to describe excellence and craft: craft put to a certain kind of … intensity. It has to do with intensity, not with a numerical thing. It is not about: Oh, she did five hundred turns. That would be a kind of … quotidian use of the word virtuosity. Or do you remember this artwork which was just a piece of paper: The artist had stared at it for a thousand hours, that’s what made it art. That’s also virtuosity. So the contemporary doesn’t abjure, doesn’t push away the concept of virtuosity. Just the term is old, it had it’s heyday perhaps in the 19th century. Today we have other terms – but I just don’t like relegating the language to fashion.</p>
<p><strong>You mentioned another term that is out of fashion: craft, “Handwerk”. It also plays an important role in your work – without dominating it.</strong></p>
<p>“Handwerk” is the foundation, it is the springboard. Without it, your ability to differentiate would be less … hm … I have to think, how can I say it without being undiplomatic … Well, let’s say: “Handwerk” is useful. (Laughs) Craft is useful, craft is a large percentage of it and if you are lucky enough you’ll be able to bring it over into art – the best people combine the two. Dana Caspersen is so skilled – but she works her fucking ass off!</p>
<p><strong>So it is – to use another outdated word – about discipline?</strong></p>
<p>Discipline is very interesting. It has to come from within. You realize that certain portions of your time are not available for other things. It is just like: That’s what needs to be done. It is kind of being very practical. You know: This ridiculous notion that art is impractical and disorganised. It is just the opposite: Artist are extremely focused people, the best ones are the most focused ones.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>There is a Word for People Like You: Audience. The Spectator as Bad Witness and Bad Voyeur</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/there-is-a-word-for-people-like-you-audience/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 22 Dec 2022 19:37:07 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/there-is-a-word-for-people-like-you-audience/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[An audience comes to a theatre perhaps to see something which if they saw it in real life, they may find offensive… Perhaps you’ve come here this evening, because you want to see something you’ve only done in the privacy of your own homes, something perhaps you wished you’d done in the privacy of your [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><p><strong>An audience comes to a theatre perhaps to see something which if they saw it in real life, they may find offensive… Perhaps you’ve come here this evening, because you want to see something you’ve only done in the privacy of your own homes, something perhaps you wished you’d done in the privacy of your own homes or something that you dreamed about doing in the privacy of your own homes. An audience likes to sit in the dark and to watch other people do it. Well, if you’ve paid your money – good luck to you.</strong></p></blockquote>
<p>However, from this end of the telescope things look somewhat different – you all look very small, and very far away and there’s a lot of you. It’s important to remember that there are more of you than of us. So, if it does come to a fight, you will undoubtedly win.</p>
<p>The audience should not forget that they are in the majority, as Richard Lowdon reminds them – nervously and with a ticking bomb tied to his belly – in the opening monologue of Showtime. For that means: They are responsible for what happens on stage and could stop it if necessary. But: they might also ignore the performance and trample on it.</p>
<p>The trivial fact that in theatre – as opposed to other art forms – the production inevitably takes place within the same space and time as the reception puts the audience in a risky position: that of sharing the responsibility of being a part of the whole. It is this phenomenon that has been of particular interest to Forced Entertainment, at least since the early ‘90s and that has played at least an incidental part ever since. In their works, dying is put on the stage and performers are pushed to reveal their most intimate secrets, fantasies and desires. They stand naked before us – desperately searching for some dignity or happiness – while we look on, the ever-present spectators, witnesses, voyeurs.</p>
<p>The shift in focus from communication that takes place within the play or across the stage to communication that takes place within the theatre itself – between actors and audience – has been a central concern for theatre reformers of all kinds. Such a shift has political ambitions. For it reveals that the theatre situation itself has always been a mirror of social models, be it the polis meeting at the Athenian theatre, the Baroque king forming the centrepiece of the play, or the awakening bourgeoisie building national theatres.</p>
<p>Since then, many fights have been fought with (or for) the audience; they have been shouted at, insulted, engaged, put on stage themselves or even surprised on the street. There is no longer any guarantee that the dramatic convention separating actors from the audience will be honoured. Even though the audience may no longer feel so threatened in their seats, their importance, as observers, has been recognized more than ever, even in mainstream theatres. For the most part, today’s theatre isn’t trying to break down the barriers between actors and audience, but is instead striving to empower the spectator as the “sovereign master over all possible kinds of semiosis”. (Erika Fischer-Lichte)</p>
<p>The audience is asked not so much to act, but rather to see and to think actively. In Brecht’s theatre, the ‘active spectator’ – the polar opposite to the Aristotelian concept of ‘fear and pity’ – was expected to apply what was shown on stage as a concrete model to society. The contemporary audience, meanwhile, is asked to relate texts and images to themselves, to make connections between often disparate elements, to supplement what they’ve seen and heard on stage in order to make their own stories, rather than follow a closed, linear narrative. Thus activated and empowered, the spectator has a peculiar responsibility for what he sees:</p>
<blockquote><p><strong>You are as responsible for everything you see as you were for everything you do. The problem was that you didn’t always know what you were seeing until later, maybe years later, it just stayed stored in your eyes.</strong></p></blockquote>
<p>It was Tim Etchells himself who in his collection of essays, Certain Fragments, placed this quote from the notes of Vietnam War reporter Michael Herr in the context of the work of Forced Entertainment: “We always loved the idea in this – of one’s responsibility for events only seen“. It is the responsibility of a person who happens to witness an event, an accident, a crime, an injustice, or even a love scene, a scene of reconciliation, or simply an everyday event. It is the responsibility of seeing – and of having an attitude towards what is seen.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>We need to create alternative Moments of Commemoration</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/we-need-to-create-alternative-moments-of-commemoration/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 22 Dec 2022 09:54:24 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1686</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[You proposed Two Minutes of Standstill as a project to Impulse Theater Biennale with the aim to interrupt the daily life of the city of Cologne on June 28th, 2013 for two minutes. What was the initial idea behind this collective performance? I was thinking about what it would mean to lend the ritual of the [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>You proposed <em>Two Minutes of Standstill</em> as a project to Impulse Theater Biennale with the aim to interrupt the daily life of the city of Cologne on June 28th, 2013 for two minutes. What was the initial idea behind this collective performance?</strong></p>
<p>I was thinking about what it would mean to lend the ritual of the Yom HaShoa – the Israeli memorial day for the victims and heroes of the Holocaust – to Germany. Every year on this day sirens in public spaces sound all over Israel, and the whole country comes to a halt to observe two minutes of silence.</p>
<p>I have been exploring state and social rituals for many years in order to understand how they form national identity. The first work I made about this was <em>Trembling Time</em> (2001), a video about the Yom HaZikaron, the Israeli Soldiers Memorial Day, which functions in practically the same way as the Holocaust Memorial Day. These rituals are national ceremonies and anchored in state law. In <em>Trembling Time</em> I tried to come to a more distant and at the same time more personal interpretation of this very emotionally charged ritual. What does it mean for an individual – for me as a citizen of the state of Israel – to be raised with such collective rituals? How can one stay an individual and self-responsible within this situation?</p>
<p><strong>But do collective commemorations then make sense for you at all? Or is that something that can only be done individually anyhow?</strong></p>
<p>Well, the purpose is to create a narrative of a nation, an identity for the state – that is not unique to Israel. I am not against that but I want to question and to analyze it.</p>
<p><strong>The regulations on how to commemorate are quite defined, there is only a small established path on which one can move. It means that commemoration becomes a pre-formulated routine – instead of being lived and lived up to.</strong></p>
<p>I strongly feel that Germany needs to create alternative moments of commemoration which, for example, also include newcomers – a ritual that refers to the present day and future and not only to history. Thousands of younger Israelis have moved to Germany in the last years. And many of them – like me – live in mixed relationships. That makes it even more obvious. We have to deal with our history together. So rather than talking about guilt, it is more about what history means to us today. We ought to commemorate the past but acknowledge the present.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“People are hostile because they only can vote every couple of years!”</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/david_van_reybrouck/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 20 Dec 2022 17:27:50 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1628</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Our “Truth is concrete” project raises the question of the usefulness of art. And the question if – as Geert Wilders infamously stated – art has indeed become a leftist hobby. What do we have to learn from the populist strategies of our opponents? Do we have to become populist ourselves in order not to [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Our “Truth is concrete” project raises the question of the usefulness of art. And the question if – as Geert Wilders infamously stated – art has indeed become a leftist hobby. What do we have to learn from the populist strategies of our opponents? Do we have to become populist ourselves in order not to just leave the terrain to the right? Was it that what you were proposing with your book “A Plea for Populism”?</strong></p>
<p>In 2008, when the book was published, I lived in Holland and got growingly frustrated with the ease with which populism was used as an insult to do away with political adversaries. Whenever you didn’t agree with someone you called him a populist and that was the end of the story. There was something profound populist in calling people populist. It was an too easy criticism. If you want to fight the popularity of the right it will not be enough to criticise populist leaders. You have to understand the reasons why so many people are inclined to vote for them. Rather than aiming our criticism at populist leaders we should direct our mercy to their voters.</p>
<p><strong>So what is the reason for the popularity of populists?</strong></p>
<p>For me it seems a very logical consequence of the social developments imposed by Europe. Developments that have weakened traditional society structures and have produced new forms of social organisation. In Belgium and the Netherlands we talk of the three pillars of society: The Christian pillar, the socialist pillar and the liberal pillar – and everybody used to belong to one of them. Belgium is a heavily pillarised country: If you were born a Catholic in the 1940s you most likely would go to a catholic school, perhaps a catholic university. You would vote for the catholic party, your health insurance would be catholic, you would go to a catholic hospital and would be buried in a catholic cemetery. From the cradle to the grave you were surrounded by catholic services and institutions. Same held true for the socialist and the liberal freethinking traditions.<br />
This system, which structured the relation between individuals and the state, has lost its importance. The role of the civil society – in Dutch called middenveld (midfield) – has been replaced by commercial media. It was the moment when in the 1950s people stayed home to watch television instead of going to a card game evening organised by the socialist union, for example. I think, Habermas was the first one to point this out in “Strukturwandel der Öffentlichkeit”. Habermas says, Öffentlichkeit (public sphere) is the place where individuals come together to form the we. The place where they become citizens. And he already observed in 1964 that the arrival of television was changing the public sphere as we had known it since the late 18th century.<br />
My grandfathers have died by now. Back in the late 1940s and 50s when they were young adults – I come from a catholic background – they were incredibly motivated by the emancipation that was offered by the three pillars: One was a small-time worker and bookbinder who became a musician and was very interested in the arts. The other one was a bricklayer and a farmer. When he died, we found a library full of books, all funded by Davidsfonds, a catholic cultural association. There is something patronising to it, but at the same time it was a structure that invited factory workers to improve their moral skills, their intellectual skills, to be curious, to start travelling – it was a window to the world.<br />
If my grandfathers would live today, they would watch a lot of television, which prime ambition is not to emancipate them but to make them addicted. That’s what commercial media do: Lure as many people as possible into watching their programs and lure advertisers to give as much money as possible. If my grandparents would live today and all their social and moral input would come from commercial media, they would be populist voters, I am damn sure. Would they be bad people for that matter? I don’t think so.</p>
<p><strong>So it is mainly a lack of education and self-emancipation that leads to the rise of populism.</strong></p>
<p>It is inevitable that populist parties are highly successful in this situation of a heavily commercially mediatised, post-industrial world. I am always surprised, how people can be surprised about this. In fact, one of the easiest jobs these days is to be a populist politician. It is such a simple recipe. If the three of us had a cynical mind-set we’d become massively popular. It is so damn easy.<br />
I don’t think we realise to what extent European democracy is under pressure. We see it already in Greece – the cradle of democracy – and in Italy: The leaders of their governments are not elected! And they are applauded for that. I am sure they are highly competent. But it is very dangerous that we applaud the fact that technocrats have taken over from democrats. There is obviously something fundamentally problematic with the democratic system or its procedures.</p>
<p><strong>Populism is a threat to our democracies, but it is to an extent also is produced by them…</strong></p>
<p>… yes, we have become electoral fundamentalists, and by this I mean: We believe that democracy essentially boils down to having elections every four years according to certain procedural standards. We believe this is the only way of running a democracy. Populism is also a result of our electoral system, of a post-industrial society, commercially mediatised with an electoral fundamentalism on top. Populist leaders are successful political entrepreneurs. They try to catch as many bystanders as possible. They work in a capitalistic logic. Voting is no longer seen as a system that brings support for certain political programmes but rather as a constant popularity test.</p>
<p><strong>Which is enhanced by new communication tools offered by the internet.</strong></p>
<p>New social media obviously change politics rapidly. They bring a culture of permanent reportage, permanent newsfeed, permanent feed-back. That changes also how you work as a politician. You are much more afraid of your voters. The biggest enemy nowadays are the own voters. You have to continuously make sure that they still support you. That produces a permanent nervousness or even neurosis.<br />
That is why democracy nowadays should not be limited to making us vote every four years on a Sunday morning in a post office. We are living in a time when information is circulating very fast. We can follow political changes by the second. Every second we can mobilise through Facebook, Twitter and we can rally people around our ideas. We have many ideas – but the only time we have real power is once every four years to make a cross next to someone’s name. How absurd is that? How archaic?<br />
This sort of procedure was invented two centuries ago. We are riding with a horse on a freeway. And at the same time you see so much commitment. Political interest is larger than ever – but trust in political parties is lower than ever. That is a very dangerous situation.<br />
This is almost a pre-revolutionary climate. But at the same time it is also an asset. It is fantastic that people are fighting on Facebook and that they are even hostile towards each other on the newspaper’ online forum. It shows commitment. Why not trying to see it as something positive? It is a source of information, a massive source of political preferences, ideas, arguments. Innovative ideas that are not used. It is just the wisdom of the crowd. So let us take this wisdom of the crowd as something valuable.</p>
<p><strong>This was the reason for you to create last year the <em>G1000</em> summit, an assembly hundreds of Belgium citizens?</strong></p>
<p>The G1000 was a result of the long period that Belgium did not have a government. We had the impression that politicians – rather then finding a reasonable compromise – were predominantly concerned with the next elections. For possibly the first time in history the weight of the next election became already in the very beginning heavier then the weight of the previous one. Obama started one and a half year after the election with his new campaign. In Belgium they started one and a half days after the election.<br />
So the reason to start the G1000 was: Let us try to get away from this nervous model of having elections every four years and making sure that you are going to win them. Let us remember that democracy in its essence is nothing else than Habermas said: People coming together and talking about the organisation of societies.<br />
Belgian political opinion is a bit like the internet before the arrival of Wikipedia. You have many ideas but no structure to bring those together and to a higher level. So the G1000 was a bit of a wiki in an offline form. You see this diversity of ideas, see the enthusiasm to talk about politics! People are frustrated. Why are they so hostile on the internet? Because they only can once every couple of years, of course!<br />
People at the G1000 came together for an entire day to discuss major issues, social and political challenges in Belgium. They talked for ten hours at 85 tables: Non-professional politicians, citizens. There wasn’t a single table where people were fighting with each other. We had 704 participants in our lecture hall, and there were a thousand more on 55 places all over Belgium and on the internet. Only two people in Brussels walked out! And it was a beautiful bank holiday. So people are dedicated. And they were happy that their voice could be heard in a different way.</p>
<p><strong>But how did you choose the participants? Who was allowed to raise her or his voice?</strong></p>
<p>That was our biggest challenge. We decided that people could not apply but would be selected – we chose this option to create a greater diversity. Not only the people that would anyway apply for this kind of event: highly educated, motivated, politicised already. I was thinking of my mother. My mother would never ever apply for this. She doesn’t think that she is knowledgeable of politics and yet if she would be contacted by our recruiting office, she’d do it because she’d feel invited. We worked together with a market survey company and they made thousands of phone calls. It worked. We got people who we’d never reach otherwise. There was even an extra recruitment for people of social groups that are difficult to access: elderly people, homeless people, people from ethnic minorities.</p>
<p><strong>You worked with quota?</strong></p>
<p>Yes, we had four quota: Gender, language, age and province. Our sample had to be in line with the national demography. And then there were three other criteria: age, educational level and profession. We used these three to correct the samples.<br />
It worked quite well – but of course not ideal, because it was a civil initiative, that nobody had heard of it before. It was easier to convince people who had heard of it before. And we couldn’t give the participants an incentive. We didn’t have a budget to offer everybody 100 Euro. My idea was to have a tombola where one would win 5000 Euro. But we didn’t do it. Which is a pity.</p>
<p><strong>So the people came just out of interest and engagement.</strong></p>
<p>Yes, many said: It is great that my voice can be heard. There was a willingness to use democracy in a radically different way. I think elections are still valuable but Western countries should develop systems of citizen participation in-between them. There are different organisations are working on this. If there was to be more deliberate democracy and less representative democracy, populist leaders would have much less chance.</p>
<p><strong>Several resolutions were formulated at the G1000, how did you get to get to results?</strong></p>
<p>There were several sessions, each of them lasted two hours. At the end, resolutions were voted. We had three main topics and two open sessions. The topics were not defined by the organisers but online before. The people decided to talk about three topics: Migration, social security and welfare in times of major crisis. There were two academic experts on the main stage who introduced each topic briefly in ten minutes each – one from the French speaking, one from the Flemish speaking side. Then the tables had an hour to discuss the topic, following a very strict, neatly timed protocol. This session started with very personal and emotional feelings and then moved to issues people agreed on at their table. At the end of the hour, the notes of each table were picked up and brought to a central desk. Hundreds of ideas from the different tables were collected there. The highest rated ideas from different tables were projected on the main screen, so everybody could see them. And then every participant had a tool like a small mobile phone with which he or she could vote. It was a very simple procedure. At the end people not always were happy with the final results – “My ideas aren’t there!” – but they could live with the fact that their idea did not make it to the end.</p>
<p><strong>There was no major disappointment?</strong></p>
<p>We had international monitors running around, international observers like at the elections in Congo. They were academic experts, people from the European Union, from all over Europe. They checked with the participants: Are you happy? Do you feel understood?<br />
Deliberative democracy can be organised in such a way that give less importance to consensus…</p>
<p><strong>… a major ideal of the Occupy movements…</strong></p>
<p>… and focus rather on compromise. People can live with compromise. In a strict electoral democracy, compromise is seen as a form of treason. Nowadays whenever a compromise is reached, the hardliners start howling. This shouting of the hardliners paralyses the finding of compromises, paralyses negotiations.</p>
<p><strong>Since you were quoting Habermas: He describes the ideal of a consensus democracy. Chantal Mouffe argues that we need to outlive our differences in an agonistic way, so the differences do not lead to total confrontation, to antagonism. You are talking about compromises…</strong></p>
<p>That’s a crucial point. As much as I am impressed by the work of Habermas, I am also impressed by the work of Chantal Mouffe. Habermas thinks that consensus is possible and that democracy should create procedures to find it. He believes that there can be a “herrschaftsfreier Diskurs” (power-free discourse), a space of neutral, objective, rational behaviour. For Chantal Mouffe this is not the case. For her at the very heart of democracy is not consensus but conflict. I am quite charmed by this definition since it tries to make the conflict manageable.<br />
I had the chance to talk to her about that – I am personally very influenced by theories of non-violent communication, in my private life but also in my work as historian of the Congo. I am fascinated by the theories of Marshall Rosenberg, an American psychologist, on non-violent communication.<br />
Also in non-violent communication you praise conflict. You don’t try to do away with it. You don’t see conflict as something that ends the negotiation, you see it as a fruitful starting point for further negotiations. And you try to find a form of compromise. We are talking about three things: consensus, conflict, compromise.<br />
It is true that some forms of conflict are irreducible. But the conflict model that we use is dating back to the 19th century. Look at today, here in Brussels there is a general strike happening. This clash was prepared, it was clear that it would happen. It is the 19th century model: Those who take care of the employees and those who take care of the employers build up their confrontation. And it was obvious that a compromise could have been reached instead of a national strike. But somehow the procedures we use are not helping us to live with the conflict but are rather magnifying it.<br />
So the procedures of the state are a bit behind the ones of the G1000 project: Let’s not promote consensus. Let’s celebrate disensus. But also let’s reach compromises.<br />
We had 85 tables with each about ten people sitting around them. They were randomly seated to guarantee maximum diversity. You would have a young African guy sitting next to an elderly lady with rather racist inclinations, next to a factory worker and next to a lawyer. And everybody behaved respectfully and sensible to differences They did not do away with differences.</p>
<p><strong>So what were the compromises that were reached? What were the results of the G1000?</strong></p>
<p>It was planned as a three phase rocket: First lets find the agenda. Then lets define shared priorities. And now we are approaching the third phase: Lets define concrete solutions. This will happen in what we call the G32 because 32 citizens were selected to continue the process. They have to be available on three weekends, it is a lot of work – 350 people were applying for it! It is amazing to what extent people want to be involved.<br />
They have been selected also in terms of diversity. And they have to respect the shared priorities that were voted at the G1000.<br />
So the G32 has three weekends to find concrete solutions, and they can ask any expert they want. The three issues voted as the most popular at the G1000 are ideas that are rarely seen in one political programme together:  First: Companies should pay less taxes as an impetus to their investment. At the moment here companies have to pay 33% but the real big ones don’t pay any. So lets make sure everyone pays 18%. This is a rule a liberal party would be very happy about. But the next rule was: Lets have a tax on financial transactions. Which is a traditional idea of the left. The third thing was to make sure we have more ecological taxes. So the outcome was a combination of a very different set of taxations and priorities as you would find it in this way never in one political programme.<br />
So during the next months people will be working on these issues and then we will hand it over to the national parliament and senate – and hopefully will start a discussion between the G32 and members of the parliament. This is the first wave of G1000 work and we will see, if we can continue as an organisation for political and democratic innovation.</p>
<p><strong>You are a writer – and your tool would be to write about these things. But you stepped out of this medium in order to engage politically. We met many artists in politically charged situations like in Cairo, and one question was always raised: What can I do within my own medium? Do I stop being an artist and am just a citizen when I act politically? Or is there room for political action within my art?</strong></p>
<p>It is true, I started as a writer and all of the sudden I am leading an organisation for political reform. I am a fairly individual artist and now I am running a programme with 50 collaborators and 800 volunteers. I find myself in this hyper-social environment and it doesn’t feel like me. But I am doing it because I believe in it and also because it is fun. But it is not as much fun as writing. I have to stretch the limits of what I usually do.<br />
To be a social activist within my own literature I would find very hard. Obviously I don’t see myself writing a play on the crisis of democracy in todays Europe. That would be too instrumental for my taste. Especially in my poetry and my plays I try to understand the state of mind or the compassion of people. The compassion that stimulates you to be political active or to be a good mother of father etc. Much of my work is on solitude and on despair. Ideally I think, an artist shouldn’t mingle with the social politics of his time; but it hasn’t been ideal for the past 2000 years so.</p>
<p><strong>So what is the role of art in a time like this? When our democracy is under</strong> threat?</p>
<p>Art is very important! Artists should be on the forefront. As an artist you are used to have freedom. If you grant yourself a life of freedom, it also should be free of taboos. To think of democracy without elections or beyond elections was a complete taboo. But the moment you start thinking about it, it is very liberating. As an artist, you can do so. We have this formidable technical tool which is language. We tried to cast some of these complex ideas and thoughts when we published the manifesto of the G1000. I wrote it and many of us gave comments. I am using a skill, but I don’t regard it a literary text. I don’t regard “A Plea for Populism” a literary text, I consider it a political analysis.</p>
<p><strong>You also write for theatre. If one looks at the photos of the summit and hears you talking about it, it sounds like a theatrical set. You have an audience that performs itself – like in a Brechtian <em>Lehrstück</em>. You could think of theatre as a model where you can try out democratic procedures.</strong></p>
<p>I like the metaphor, but I haven’t conceived the project through this metaphor. And to be honest: I would find it silly to turn it into a performance.</p>
<p><strong>But theatre has always been a place where society has been rehearsing itself: From the Greek polis to the baroque stages where the monarch was the centre of everything to the bourgeois theatre of the 19th century to Brecht. The space of the theatre, the setup, the way how the audience is addressed, was always related to the system of society. It is not only an architecture, it is a performative space that offers a possibility for trying out and thinking.</strong></p>
<p>You should write an essay about it! I love it. Hey, I will steal this idea for one chapter in my book on democracy I am planning to write. It is an interesting metaphor. And indeed most European parliaments have the same architecture as the Greek theatre.</p>
<p><strong>Even the problem of representation, you are addressing with the G1000, is mirrored by the limits of representational theatre, where you sit and watch what others tell you. It is not only a question of text, it is a question of the space. Like Godard said: The problem is not to make political films, but to make films politically. How can you turn your art into a political situation?</strong></p>
<p>On a deeper level, I could sympathise with that metaphor. But on a direct level and In terms of building up an own oeuvre – no. In general, I feel very much in line with Albert Camus. After having written a number of his books, he got involved with the Algerian independence movement and tried something actually very similar to the G1000 in the war between the Algerians and the French. He tried to bring some peace and rationality back to the debate. And he was completely unsuccessful. It was a runaway train and he couldn’t stop it anymore. When I was setting up the G1000 I thought: I hope I am not too late. But I don’t think Camus and his interventions were artistic manifestations. He did this as a citizen.<br />
I sympathise with the idea of making the theatre more political; not because it talks about politics but because of the very fact that it in itself can be political. But I am also massively frustrated that it has become such a middle class entertainment industry. One of the main motives in “A Plea for Populism” was that the populist logic can also be explained by the growing division between people who are highly educated and those who only studied until they were eighteen or even less. I am frustrated by the fact that theatre has a hard time to find new audiences. So to create a more political theatre which is still only working for the same highly educated middle-class audience – I find it rather pointless.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>The Other&#8217;s Laughter: Doing Theory</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/the-others-laughter-doing-theory/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 18 Dec 2022 17:14:05 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/the-others-laughter-doing-theory/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Thinking in art is not valued too highly. On the one hand – too much conceptual dance, all that brainy theatre, enigmatic images and installations, all that stuff-in-progress, too little beauty, too little emotion, too little flesh and blood. On the other hand: thinking in art enjoys great esteem. There is scarcely a theatre, a [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Thinking in art is not valued too highly. On the one hand – too much conceptual dance, all that brainy theatre, enigmatic images and installations, all that stuff-in-progress, too little beauty, too little emotion, too little flesh and blood. On the other hand: thinking in art enjoys great esteem. There is scarcely a theatre, a festival, or a museum that wouldn’t now and then resort to a “laboratory”, an academy, an “educational” or “research programme”; manifesta, documenta, summer academies, education is all over the place. In the meantime, it has become self-understandable to link theory and practice without a clear demarcation of spheres, to find places and formats for the representatives of art, theory, and everyday life and to work out something in common – with the high claim of not only mediating, but also producing theory. But is it the task of a festival, a theatre, an exhibition house, which eventually obtain their tax moneys for producing and presenting art, to do research, to enforce discourses, to mediate and create knowledge?</p>
<p>Perhaps they should rather focus on the core business: curtain up, curtain down. Vernissage, finissage.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">* * * * *</p>
<p>There are no real beginnings: they are made retrospectively. Hans Blumenberg has once told such a story, which should open our eyes to the apparently absolute incompatibility of theory and practice. Referring to an ancient Aesop’s fable in his “Theaetetus”, Plato described a sort of early philosophical accident: Thales of Miletus – and astronomer in the sense of proto-philosopher, who has often been retrospectively called the founder of Greek philosophy – stepped out of his house one night in order to contemplate the stars. Deeply focused on his heavenly objects in the manner of an absent-minded professor, he tumbled down into a well of water. A far more practical handmaid, who was witnessing the embarrassing situation, laughed at him and jested, “that he was so eager to know what was going on in heaven, that he could not see what was before his feet. This is a jest which is equally applicable to all philosophers.” (Plato).</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Dramaturgies of care and insecurity: The story of Rimini Protokoll</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/dramaturgies-of-care-and-insecurity-the-story-of-rimini-protokoll/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 13 Dec 2022 10:38:36 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/dramaturgies-of-care-and-insecurity-the-story-of-rimini-protokoll/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[A man comes on stage and shows some slides of chickens. He talks about deep litter systems, key issues of feeding, pest control, slaughter. The audience is baffled or amused, three or four are angered. After an hour of slides it is time for questions: questions about poultry farming and questions about representation in theatre. [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A man comes on stage and shows some slides of chickens. He talks about deep litter systems, key issues of feeding, pest control, slaughter. The audience is baffled or amused, three or four are angered. After an hour of slides it is time for questions: questions about poultry farming and questions about representation in theatre. But does the man on the rehearsal stage of the Giessen Institute for Applied Theatre Studies actually know that everybody here expected something completely different – a real performance but not a real person? And is the audience really sure that Herr Heller is real – an expert in poultry farming and not acting?</p>
<p><em>Peter Heller spricht über Geflügelhaltung</em> (<em>Peter Heller talks about Poultry Farming</em>) from 1997 is a candidate for the prototypical origin of Rimini Protokoll’s theatre. The idea arose in a student bar in Giessen, around a large table, over beer and schnitzel. Stefan Kaegi, who had just recently arrived in this small town in Hessen from the F+F art school in Zurich, had a real poultry farmer up his sleeve already. He had actually come for just half a year to see whether there was anything to learn at the institute, founded by Andrzej Wirth in 1982. The conservative paper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung later described it as “the greatest source of calamity for German theatre” because this was where, amongst others, René Pollesch, She She Pop, Showcase Beat Le Mot and (some members of) Gob Squad emerged to challenge or undermine conventional state-supported theatre. The Institute for Applied Theatre Studies was, and in this respect still remains, the only German-speaking university department to combine theatre theory and practice and above all to dedicate itself to the production of contemporary and experimental theatre forms.</p>
<p>In this context Peter Heller was a quickly produced experiment, a theatrical game designed to irritate those who, through their studies, were constantly having to deal with the irritation of theatre. A theatrical readymade. For Stefan Kaegi and Bernd Ernst (who came to Giessen in the same year as Kaegi), it was the first in a series of inquiries into how powerful the black box is as a representation machine and how far whatever you place in it automatically becomes theatre. But also how the view of the black box is changed through that which is placed in it.</p>
<p>After <em>Peter Heller</em>, Bernd Ernst and Stefan Kaegi staged productions featuring a pedigree Great Dane and a neurotic ufologist followed. In 1999 they named themselves <em>Hygiene Heute</em> (<em>Hygiene Today</em> – in opposition to dusty old German theatre), producing their first full-length show <em>Training 747</em> for the Staatstheater Darmstadt’s Cutting Edge Festival. The piece was an intricate and playful story about mysterious parallels between two legendary aeroplane landings: the crash landing of Joseph Beuys’s bomber in the 2nd World War and amateur pilot Mathias Rust’s landing near Moscow’s Red Square. At that point their interest in theatrical readymades had already been replaced by the desire to create complex theatrical events.</p>
<p>There are other precedents for Rimini’s origins however. Fellow Giessen students Marcus Droß, Helgard Haug und Daniel Wetzel had been developing performances since 1995 under the name <em>Ungunstraum – Alles zu seiner Zeit</em> (<em>Unfavourable Space – Everything in its Time</em>). These performances worked above all on discarding or explicitly revealing theatrical mechanisms. In doing so, they also repeatedly put non-professionals on stage as “experts” for particular functions.</p>
<p>The three found each other in the context of a scenic project set by the composer and director Heiner Goebbels who was guest professor at the Institute at the time. The basis for the students’ project was Kafka’s story fragment <em>The Great Wall of China</em> and so the 1st Stage of Ungunstraum led us on an imaginary journey from Giessen to Peking. The group subsequently called almost all their series of related performances and installations at the time stages (Etappen). There was no recognisable narrative – actually almost nothing recognisable at all. Factual train connections to the Great Wall replaced Kafka’s text. The performers too disappeared in an installation made from steamed-up panes that could be written and projected on, as well as all kinds of sound and technical equipment. The performer-self (to say nothing of the actor-self) was regarded very critically. “Something had driven us onto the stage but then we hid ourselves the whole time we were there.” (Haug)</p>
<p>The name Ungunstraum came from a brochure about China that highlighted the “difficulty of transporting people and goods in a country with extremely unfavourable spaces (Ungunsträume)”. Droß, Haug und Wetzel wanted their ‘unfavourable spaces’ to demonstrate precisely where for them, infrastructure appeared to overwhelm form and content more than in other art forms: in the theatre. They were suspicious of technical perfection. Their task as performers was to operate and serve the light and sound equipment placed in full view on the stage and not to play themselves. The more polished and carefully built the settings became, the more their own appearance on stage was mistrusted. They wanted to be “professional dilettantes”, – following the only half-ironic maxim: “rehearsing is for cowards”.</p>
<p>The trap of representation (and that was essentially the whole of the German theatre landscape) was to be avoided at any price, and was considered at Giessen, more than anywhere else, the primary cause of all theatrical ills. Everything pleasing, everything that could be accused of trying “to give an audience what it wanted”, everything that concerned “purely visual effects and surface, that was to do with conventional dramaturgy stood under the general charge of non-thinking” (Wetzel).</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>No outside. Nowhere. Theatre critics’ struggle for criteria, distance. And, of course, money.</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/no-outside-nowhere-theatre-critics-struggle-for-criteria-distance-and-of-course-money/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 12 Dec 2022 20:28:47 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/no-outside-nowhere-theatre-critics-struggle-for-criteria-distance-and-of-course-money/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Finally, criticism only exists in relation to something other than itself: it is an instrument, a means to a future, or to a truth, which it neither knows nor will become, it is a glimpse of an area that it would like to police, but can’t enforce its law.Michel Foucault A black chambermaid in the [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><p><strong>Finally, criticism only exists in relation to something other than itself: it is an instrument, a means to a future, or to a truth, which it neither knows nor will become, it is a glimpse of an area that it would like to police, but can’t enforce its law.</strong>Michel Foucault</p></blockquote>
<p>A black chambermaid in the large, marble, box-like set mops the floor, mops and mops, her movement becoming slower, becoming slow motion. Then, after a blackout with loud booming white noise: absolute silence. As if all sound were turned off. And in the silence, in the harsh, bare marble room sits a baby alone, only a few months old, sits and looks incredulous. Hesitatingly, without lifting its gaze from the audience, it reaches out for a black cup, knocks it over, and three dice roll over the white floor. A surreal dream, a film scene perhaps, but with an electric physical presence. And the audience barely dares to breathe, so as not to disturb the child, so as not to disturb the image. So as not to be saddled with the responsibility.</p>
<p>How does one capture presence with language? With what criteria does one judge the performance of a baby? Are they allowed to do that? What ethical principles are valid for art? What is one describing when there is no plot, no acting, and no dialogue to describe? How true is memory?</p>
<p>The job of the critic isn’t exactly made easier by the fact that theatre is increasingly unwilling to take a text and more or less cautiously or violently heave it onto a stage, interpret it, illustrate it, or embody it. Criteria for good or bad have always been a construction in art and life, a difficult-to-separate mix of relative agreement about the latest discourse and one’s own private opinion. However, as long as it is clear that it is about more or less successfully staging a drama, as long as the text always comes first and everything else follows it, as long as the actor (regardless of whether psychological or artificial, whether very physical or very ethereal, whether over-aestheticised or humble) plays a reasonably clear and defined role, as long as the actor plays a role at all, then you at least have something to hold onto while writing the review. And if you nevertheless are still clueless, you can always praise or complain about the diction of the main actor.</p>
<p><strong>Text, movement, space, sound, lighting, whatever</strong></p>
<p>Those were the days. Nowadays you can be happy when an actor is involved at all, and if the critic has to evaluate or at least describe the performative ability (and ‘presence’) of completely paralysed people with motor neuron disease (in a work of the German theatre- and filmmaker Christoph Schlingensief at the Volksbühne, Berlin) or of computer-playing youths, old ladies, unemployed air traffic controllers and Indian call centre workers (all in the work of Rimini Protokoll), of eagerly performing professional dilettantes (e.g. Baktruppen or their successors Showcase Beat le Mot), or even – as in the above described opening scene of the fourth part of <em>Romeo Castellucci’s Tragedia Endogondia</em> – of a nine-month-old child.</p>
<p>The critical reflection about the actor’s work and his role is one of the most obvious aesthetic indications of contemporary ‘experimental’ theatre. Among other reasons it results from a mistrust of traditional acting skills with their often predictable tricks, but its roots are deeper; the ‘as if’ of the conventional theatrical pact is not, for many theatre-makers, a feasible starting point anymore. The critique of representation, above all the psychoanalytically influenced French post-structuralism and its variants, has necessarily also called into question the theatrical machinery of representation. Such theatre often does not want to show any other kind of reality, but rather create a situation that is in itself real. In this way, the borders between acting and performance, representation and presentation dissolve, as do many of the customary criteria for analysis and assessment. Where the text does not necessarily have the first word, any system of signs can come to the fore in order to demand attention and be the starting point also of a critique. Movement, space, sound, light, whatever. Perhaps even presence.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Cause &#038; Result: Curating Performing Arts</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/cause-result-curating-performing-arts/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 12 Dec 2022 16:18:21 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/cause-result-curating-performing-arts/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[What comes first Determines what can happen next, and what happens next alters what has come beforeJonathan Burrows &#38; Matteo Fargion Cheap Lecture Around the artist, around art. Among the professions that are rather close to art or even right within, but not artistic themselves, not directly artistic themselves, the curator has the youngest and [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><p><strong>What comes first<br />
Determines<br />
what can happen<br />
next, and what<br />
happens<br />
next<br />
alters what has<br />
come<br />
before</strong>Jonathan Burrows &amp; Matteo Fargion <em>Cheap Lecture</em></p></blockquote>
<p>Around the artist, around art. Among the professions that are rather close to art or even right within, but not artistic themselves, not directly artistic themselves, the curator has the youngest and most unclear profile. In the visual arts, where he became a star within a short time, he is standing in the midst of a controversy that is essentially driven by himself. In the field of dance, theatre, and performance however, he is still rare and, above all, mostly unheeded. Which is all the more surprising since he has long played an influential role in independent performing arts, defining and organizing art, discourses, formats, and finances.</p>
<p><strong>Terminology as scarce commodity</strong></p>
<p>Well, it belongs to the profile of many jobs in the free and experimental international theatre (that is, theatre outside of the fixed structures and relatively fixed aestheticisms of the repertory city theatres, which are mostly active only within the limits of their countries and languages) that there is actually no clear profile. What does a dramaturge do without a drama, an art critic without a catalogue of criteria, a dancer without dance, a theatre director without a text that should be staged? But the theatre curator does not even have an outdated model of reference at his disposal: the terminology and job description has been borrowed from the visual arts, as their particular way of dealing with formats, with art and artists, and with economies and audiences, suddenly seemed transferrable.</p>
<p>Before that, in the 1980s and early 1990s, a good part of the independent theatre landscape had changed considerably: radically new aestheticisms, and later also new working structures and hierarchies within ensembles, collectives, and companies came into existence along with new or newly defined theatre houses and festivals. Above all, the concept of the kunstencentra, which with their open, mostly interdisciplinary approaches paved the way for many of today’s scene-heroes and re-classified the audience, spilled over from Belgium and the Netherlands into the neighbouring countries and made it possible to reinvent theatre as an institution.</p>
<p>With them arrived a new, often charismatically filled professional profile: that of the programme maker (who, depending on the institution, would be officially called artistic director, Intendant, dramaturge, manager, producer). As the name already shows, the accent was on taking a grip on things, on making. A generation of men of action defined the course of events – and even if their attitude seems occasionally patriarchal from today’s point of view, the scene was actually less male-biased than the society and the city theatres around it. This generation of founders, which at the same time redefined and imported the model of the dramaturge, established some remarkably efficient and stabile structures and publics: it was a time of invention and discovery, which has had obvious repercussions into the present day. Professional profiles were created and changed – also that of the artist himself.</p>
<p>This foundation work was largely completed by the mid-1990s at the latest (at least in the West), not least because financial resources were becoming more scarce. What followed was a generation of former assistants, of critical apprentices so to say, and with them a period of continuity, but also of differentiation, reflection, and well-tailored networks, of development and re-questioning new formats – labs and residencies, summer academies, parcours, thematic mini-festivals, emerging artist platforms&#8230; The difficulty of the plains replaces that of the mountains, the struggle over quality criteria and discourses replaces the often socio-cultural founding-impetus to let very different cultures coexist equally.</p>
<p>The picture is still dominated by transition models, but the strong specialization of the arts (exemplified by the visual arts), the subsequent specialization of the programme makers and dramaturges, and a generally altered professional world – which also here increasingly relies on free, independent, as well as cheaper labour – along with increasingly differentiated audiences, again require a different professional profile: the curator is a symptom of these changes in art, as well as in society and the market. His working fields are theatre forms that often cannot be realized within the established structures; artistic handwritings that always require different approaches; a scene that is more and more internationalized and disparate; the communication of often not easy aestheticisms; transmission and contextualization. Last but not least, the curator is the link between art and the public.</p>
<p>Whether the stolen term curator is the most suitable here for this job or not is currently a popular point of dispute and, above all, polemics. However, there is more at stake than personal gain in distinction to programme makers, who might not feel appreciated enough. And the difficulty of naming and defining this new job is just symptomatic for a genre in which terminology is a scarce commodity anyway and which does not even have a reasonably good name itself: Experimental theatre? Free theatre? All biased or misleading. Time-based art? Live art? At least attempts at defining the genres within different borders. Devised theatre, that is, a theatre that must evolve again and again from scratch? New theatre – after all these years? Postdramatic theatre? At least one successful, marketable keyword. But how does the kind of dance that has been so influential in recent years, but is also still looking for a suitable name, fit in here: conceptual dance?</p>
<p>As a clandestine romantic, one might consider the missing slate to be a subversive gain and fashion it that way in the first place – an elitist thinking in niches, but out of defensive resignation rather than self-confidence. In fact, the lack of terminology indicates above all a lack of articulation, a lack of communication not limited to advertising, a lack of more than purely intra- disciplinary discourse in the performing arts, which remain amazingly speechless in this respect. Thus it again signals the necessity of curatorial work, which – as can be seen in the visual arts, where catalogues, for example, are an integral part of almost all exhibitions – consists to a large extent of verbalization, communication, and discussion. As a part of the central task to create contexts.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Citizen of the Other Place: Christoph Schlingensief&#8217;s Trilogy of Fear and Hope</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/citizen-of-the-other-place-christoph-schlingensiefs-trilogy-of-fear-and-hope/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 12 Dec 2022 15:56:21 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1484</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Illness is the night-side of life, a more onerous citizenship. Everyone who is born holds dual citizenship, in the kingdom of the well and in the kingdom of the sick. Although we all prefer to use only the good passport, sooner or later each of us is obliged, at least for a spell, to identify [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><p><strong>Illness is the night-side of life, a more onerous citizenship. Everyone who is born holds dual citizenship, in the kingdom of the well and in the kingdom of the sick. Although we all prefer to use only the good passport, sooner or later each of us is obliged, at least for a spell, to identify ourselves as citizens of the other place.</strong>Susan Sontag</p></blockquote>
<p>Perhaps the most alarming thing is this: that there is a narrative plausibility even to Christoph Schlingensief’s cancer – as if plausibility had anything to do with life and death. We narrate our lives backwards; in retrospect, decisions seem inevitable, coincidence feasible, and the hand of fate consequential. Just as the Romantics believed that illness and early death were the result of a poetic sensibility. Just as we see an inner logic, a dramaturgy in the lives of famous people and are disinclined to read them as mere products of circumstance.</p>
<p>The neo-romantic Schlingensief has, in his work and interviews, always narrated his life in this way: as an ultimately coherent – albeit circuitous – development. He has expanded upon this narrative onstage and enlarged it via his incursions into public spaces, which in turn were taken up by the media so that they, too, have chronicled his life as it were a novel. And because Schlingensief and the world around him tend to notch things up more than just a little, he has considerably overextended the arc between life and art, as was demonstrated (if not before) in his 2004 production of <em>Parsifal</em> in Bayreuth. If an artist and his interpreters equate the two ends of this arc so strongly, couldn’t it be that the work actually writes the life? That life adheres to a desirable (because plausible, because aesthetically beautiful) logic? And, at some point, it seemed as if this life were no longer being narrated backwards, but forwards. Like a serialised novel or a film or, to cite Schlingensief’s 2008 production <em>A Church of Fear for the Stranger in Me</em>:</p>
<blockquote><p>Are we perhaps a lie? Are we a film, a film lasting barely a moment? Are we the thoughts of a madman? Are we a printing error? Are we a premonition? The picture that forms in one’s imagination much earlier than the events via which we participate in life occur? [&#8230;] Are we a future fact that has not yet come about?</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Parsifal</em> is Wagner’s final opera, an artistic and ideological legacy replete with religious motifs – from the revelation of the monstrance to the Eucharist. Following Schlingensief’s surprising appointment as the director of a new production of this opera, time and again comparisons were made between him and its title figure : <em>Parsifal</em> the ‘pure fool’ who, as a Germanised figure of salvation, redeems the world through compassion, and Schlingensief – for whom compassion and redemption, albeit often misunderstood as irony, were always central motifs in his work – who tilts in apparent naivety at windmills. Or at Klingsor.</p>
<p>The wider resonance of the <em>Parsifal</em> story was also soon to be extended by the concrete situation of the artist himself. Even with someone like Schlingensief, who has effected so many surprising yet convincing artistic turnarounds, it was difficult to imagine what might follow the supposed highpoint of a production at the Bayreuth Festspielhaus. The enfant terrible, trash filmmaker, scandalous performer, and TV provocateur had entered the heart of bourgeois culture. It would be difficult for an artistic career to reach a more established or esteemed position than this. The life story appeared complete – catharsis had to follow. Schlingensief, too, did not resist the temptation of ennobling his life and art with the possibility of its early end. In fact he repeatedly mentioned that death could, indeed, follow his production of Parsifal.</p>
<p><strong>Theatre as illness, illness as theatre</strong></p>
<p>Schlingensief’s fascination with illness and death did, however, not begin with Parsifal. Rather, it is a fascination that is also apparent in his early films. Blood is vomited in <em>Mother’s Mask</em> (1988) and <em>Menu Total</em> (1986) contains the eerie white-coats-and-doctors scene that would later be incorporated into the video segment of <em>Mea Culpa: A ReadyMade Opera</em> (2009). For Schlingensief, the motif of illness has various functions and meanings. It becomes a symptom of what society has suppressed, of something (the National Socialist past, incest, rape) that breaks out because it can no longer be restrained. But, in contrast to Antonin Artaud (who likened the theatre to the plague with its grotesquely transformative power), the outbreak of illness in these cases does not mark a turning point, a new social beginning, or a resurrection from the smoking ruins. It does not have a cathartic effect; it merely brings the truth to light, without leading to insight. The truth serum of illness does not heal – even though redemption is another central motif in Schlingensief’s work &#8211; perhaps for the very reason that it cannot be attained.</p>
<p>The fact that Schlingensief likes to bring up the subject of societal illness has less to do with the desire to provoke than with compassion, indeed with a vicarious suffering that sometimes lends him a touch of the messianic. The supposition of irony or even cynicism is usually incorrect here – techniques of the inauthentic or of distancing are largely foreign to Schlingensief. Rather, it is primarily the techniques of non-integration and non-resolution that are essential to his work.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>No Organum to Follow. Possibilities of Political Theatre Today</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/no-organum-to-follow-possibilities-of-political-theatre-today/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 12 Dec 2022 14:34:26 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1479</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Some people are yelling at each other with red faces, others try to stay calm whilst convincing bystanders of the threat of foreigners taking over their country. How Austria stands alone against the rest of the world. An old man almost cries while shaking a newspaper that repeats in large letters the same discussion on [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Some people are yelling at each other with red faces, others try to stay calm whilst convincing bystanders of the threat of foreigners taking over their country. How Austria stands alone against the rest of the world. An old man almost cries while shaking a newspaper that repeats in large letters the same discussion on its front page. Some Korean tourists watch the strange spectacle without a clue.</p>
<p>15 years ago, when German theatre maker Christoph Schlingensief set up his now legendary container-installation <em>Bitte liebt Österreich!</em> (<em>Please Love Austria!</em>, 2000) right in the centre of Vienna, Chancellor Wolfgang Schüssel had just made his devil’s pact with the right wing demagogue Jörg Haider, and the other EU-countries were discussing sanctions against the fellow member state. Austria debated passionately about immigration policy, as well as about the limits of art. And Europe watched with some bewilderment.</p>
<p>Under the dominating banner ‘Ausländer raus’ (‘Foreigners out!’) Schlingensief staged a <em>Big Brother</em>-type game show with asylum seekers. The containers housed a group of immigrants who could be watched via CCTV on the internet, and the Austrian population was invited to vote them out of the country one by one. The scandal was enormous: conservatives felt insulted by the seeming parody of their argumentation, and the left was disgruntled by the supposedly cynical display.</p>
<p>If political theatre can only exist in a context in which the world is believed to be changeable, in which theatre itself wants to be part of that change, and where there is an audience that is willing to actively engage in the exploration of what that change should be — then it becomes clear why it is so difficult to think of such a theatre today in a society paralysed by the symptoms of post-political ideologies that tend to disguise themselves as positivistic pragmatism, lachrymose resignation, or cheerful complacency. Where the credo of ‘There is no alternative’ (TINA) is considered common sense and the belief in the possibility or even desirability of political imagination is fading, theatre is hit at its core. All its political potential seems disabled.</p>
<p>It was a different time in the 1970s and 1980s when political theatre in Europe actually was (in different ways on either side of the Wall) a relevant factor in many public debates. With ideologies still going strong and the division between east and west clear cut, theatre engaged in everyday politics by representing all the world’s miseries — from the Vietnam War or Apartheid in South Africa to the small daily adversities of a local working class family. Either in new drama or modernised classics, radical interpretations of the text were a key feature of a <em>Regietheater</em> (director’s theatre) which, despite its many new approaches, stayed mostly in the realm of the mimetic. In the east it was a game with hidden messages, in the west open provocations were an important part of the repertoire, and audiences slamming doors while leaving was a rule rather than an exception.</p>
<p>No wonder that large parts of the public still consider this period almost synonymous with ‘political theatre’ itself. But even though the theatre during this period was often able to propose an understanding of the structural reasons behind the presented evils, it couldn’t avoid the dilemma that in the end its representations were just another repetition of the very miseries it wanted to fight. Brecht called this phenomenon ‘Menschenfresserdramatik’ (‘cannibal’s dramatic art’), which he described in the early 1930s in his notes on “Die dialektische Dramatik”: ‘The physical exploitation of the poor is followed by a psychological one’ when the pitied character is supposed to produce feelings of sadness, guilt or even anger in a spectator, who most likely — at least structurally — is part of keeping the very system of exploitation alive. In the end they continued what Brecht had already analysed in his <em>Short Organum for the Theatre</em> (1949): ‘The theatre we know shows the structure of society (represented on the stage) as incapable of being influenced by society (in the auditorium).’ Not only the play onstage but the whole theatrical set up (not to speak of the hierarchies within the institution itself) merely reproduced the system they wanted to criticise.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“How Can We Imagine a School Culture Based on Solidarity?”</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/how-can-we-imagine-a-school-culture-based-on-solidarity/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 12 Dec 2022 14:16:29 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/how-can-we-imagine-a-school-culture-based-on-solidarity/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Let’s go right away to a core dilemma of the Silent University: It is planned as a self-organized school, by and for academics who have had to leave their home countries and are unable to teach in the country where they are now living (due to their legal status, work permits, their qualifications not being [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Let’s go right away to a core dilemma of the Silent University: It is planned as a self-organized school, by and for academics who have had to leave their home countries and are unable to teach in the country where they are now living (due to their legal status, work permits, their qualifications not being accepted etc.), to enable their knowledge to be heard. But in reality the Silent University is usually founded top-down. It is your initiative. Most of the time there is an institution involved, a coordinator belonging to this institution etc. How do you deal with this contradiction?</strong></p>
<p>I’ve learned a lot since we set up the first branch of Silent University in London in 2012. It took a while to turn it from a project into a small-scale organization. Within this process, my position and involvement have been transformed too. First I was the artist who initiated it, I then became a co-coordinator and co-organizer, now I mostly act as a supervisor, and I hope soon I will become just an ordinary member, a contributor, and a guest.</p>
<p>My original plan was four years of direct involvement as an initiator, staying in one city, London. But in reality things worked differently. Now, after four years, we have three active branches in Mülheim, Hamburg, and Stockholm and new autonomous branches on the way in Athens and Amman. We have also had a failed branch in Montreuil, Paris which operated for over a year and a largely inactive branch in London because after the third year we lacked the long-term collaboration of an institution.</p>
<p>In the beginning I thought a process of preparation would be required to reach the point where the community could take over and establish its own autonomous organization. We would start by working together with institutions, securing a budget for at least one year. At first this might look like a top-down process, but it should evolve towards a bottom-up-organization. In terms of long-term stability, I thought it was a good idea to start by having institutions, a budget, a place to meet, and a local co-coordinator, while acknowledging from the outset that it was a parasitic organization.</p>
<p>I still think this is the best way to start in some countries. But nowadays we are also trying the bottom-up model in cities like Athens and Amman, starting with a group of engaged and motivated people, not with an institution or budget. We still do not know which strategy will create a more sustainable and independent autonomous organization.</p>
<p><strong>So the institution should accept a facilitating role which always adapts to local needs. Since there is a high turnover of participants—because they may move on, may have to move on etc.—the support of an institution can help to achieve stability but it should step back as soon as possible.</strong><br />
<strong>However, there is another question. So far you have always collaborated with art institutions. This has advantages. For example: they are able define their field of operations very broadly, they can make things possible and they can give a certain symbolic value to the people involved in the Silent University. However, the art world has the tendency to render things harmless. Everything it touches becomes “art”. It is part of a certain market and it has the tendency to create mainly symbolic value for its own purposes.</strong></p>
<p>I am interested in how we use the facilities art institutions can provide. We often underestimate these facilities and what they can achieve. Whether they are a large institution like Tate Modern, or medium scale institutions like The Showroom, Tensta Konsthall or Impulse Theater Festival, even smaller organizations can achieve a lot in a short period of time. How can we place something like SU inside an art institution? Not just within existing formats such as events or temporary engagements, but also by making it part of an accredited system for students, giving the Silent University&#8217;s participants direct access and even paying them to give classes. Good intentions are not enough. There is an obvious danger of turning SU into a harmless tactical collaboration. It requires an on-going process of daily negotiation to work with an art institution.</p>
<p>Saskia Sassen made a point in her keynote speech at the Creative Time Summit in Stockholm in 2014 about the importance of something being unauthorized but recognized. It&#8217;s not about replacing or imitating the existing university structure or neoliberal education system. It&#8217;s time to revolutionize, de-colonize and really transform it in an ambitious way, but by starting on a small scale. Working with art institutions and established universities is one way to gain recognition, rather than by trying to establish a new and independent group which will effectively be marginalized. Instead, we can use the facilities of those existing institutions as progressive tools. But to be able to truly do that, those institutions need to transform themselves.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Empty Stages, Crowded Flats. Performative curating performing arts</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/empty-stages-crowded-flats-performative-curating-performing-arts/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 11 Dec 2022 15:27:55 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/empty-stages-crowded-flats-performative-curating-performing-arts/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Let’s start with an image: Two, three lonely people scattered around midnight over the art deco auditory of Vooruit theatre in Gent. Meditatively leaning back in their plush seats under balconies and ambitious ornamentation, they quietly watch the half-lit stage underneath the golden letters emblazoned on the proscenium like a motto: “Kunst veredelt”, “art ennobles”. [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Let’s start with an image: Two, three lonely people scattered around midnight over the art deco auditory of Vooruit theatre in Gent. Meditatively leaning back in their plush seats under balconies and ambitious ornamentation, they quietly watch the half-lit stage underneath the golden letters emblazoned on the proscenium like a motto: “Kunst veredelt”, “art ennobles”. On the stage itself, nothing but some bunk beds. A few people sleeping; one is snoring, another one just undressing.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>&#8222;Art can&#8217;t change the world on its own&#8220;</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/art-cant-change-the-world-on-its-own/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 10 Dec 2022 14:22:20 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/art-cant-change-the-world-on-its-own/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[You mentioned once in an interview that you do not believe there is a distinction between political and non-political art and that, for you, “from the point of view of the theory of hegemony, artistic practices play a role in the constitution and maintenance of a given symbolic order or in its challenging and this [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>You mentioned once in an interview that you do not believe there is a distinction between political and non-political art and that, for you, “from the point of view of the theory of hegemony, artistic practices play a role in the constitution and maintenance of a given symbolic order or in its challenging and this is why they necessarily have a political dimension.” How do you see such art practices as the<em> Silent University</em>, which tries to empower refugees/asylum seekers who are silenced by the complex structure of hegemony?</strong></p>
<p>I have a problem with seeing the Silent University as an art project. I am very positive about it, but is it an art project? I don’t think so. Of course you can say that it is an initiative in which artists are implied. It is a project that was designed by an artist, yes, but that does not make it an art project.</p>
<p>That will probably remain an open question. Everyone involved in the <em>Silent University</em> describes it differently. One reason why we see it as an artistic project is because it plays with institutional representation. By calling itself a “university,” it references an institutional model. But in reality, on the level of governance, it is not a real university. It is a fictive structure. While it might institute something, it is not a real institution. It plays with the symbolic order and with representation. It is an artistic project, not only in its form but also by being an intervention in society using representative models. The Silent University can be seen as an NGO but it could also be seen as a municipal or government project. It is hard to describe what its institutional body is and what kind of political language it uses to speak to whom. It is important not to be able to describe what the Silent University really is. Another reason to link it to art is, of course, because it is usually hosted by an art institution.</p>
<p><strong>But that is because there are artists involved, and those are the contacts they have. What would be the difference if it was hosted by a school or a political association with no links to the art world?</strong></p>
<p>But it is also about going beyond the policies—educational policy, institutional policy, governmental policy etc. Establishing the Silent University in a government institution won’t be easy because it has to be run in a self-organized, autonomous, collective way. There is a coordinator but there are many people who provide initiatives. Some of these people might not have papers. Most institutions, including big museums, don’t really want to host refugees and asylum seekers permanently in their spaces. In this regard, smaller art institutions are easier to access.</p>
<p>I find it a bit exaggerated when people say: I am an artist, so what I do is automatically an art project. But if you insist on relating it to art, I would rather put it in the category of “artistic activism” or “artivism.” For me, this is a form of a political practice. The Silent University is definitively a political project, and artistic activism is a political project that uses artistic strategies, for instance regarding the questions about representation. So it is a political project with an important aesthetic, artistic dimension—but it is not primarily a artistic project.</p>
<p>At one end of the spectrum there are artists who want to make a political intervention—at the other there are activists who use artistic strategies. It is mainly a difference of emphasis, but this is an important distinction, a methodological question. I am in favor of both. Both are important but there are also important differences: many artivists are very critical toward artists working in the art world—they believe that if you want to make critical art you can’t work in museums, galleries or take part in biennials.</p>
<p><strong>So is it possible to make a meaningful political intervention within the field of art or, more generally, from inside an institution? Or is one required to do so from the outside—if one can make meaningful political interventions at all?</strong></p>
<p>Many people believe that you can’t make any kind of critique in the art world because you are automatically involved. I don’t agree with that. I’m always defending a pluralistic position: one should try to occupy all the places where one can make an intervention. If you have the chance to do so in a museum, in a gallery, do it! But don’t believe that this is the only way. One needs to recognize the multiplicity of spaces. That is what I am really interested in when I am thinking of those interventions in the form of artistic practices: How they can contribute to the counter-hegemonic struggle? That’s what is important for me.</p>
<p>And I think one can contribute to that struggle in many different ways and in many different places. In this regard the Silent University is an important form of practice—whether you call it “artistic” or “artivist.” It is important for the counter-hegemonic struggle because it is trying to facilitate the voices of people who are silenced. That’s very, very important.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Feeling Alive. The Performative Potential of Curating</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/feeling-alive-the-performative-potential-of-curating/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 10 Dec 2022 11:34:30 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/?post_type=content&#038;p=1456</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[The concept of curating has arrived in the field of performing arts, and with it the understanding that programming performances, theatre works, dance pieces, or music can be more than just selecting or producing shows and then inserting them into a time slot and space. There is a necessity of putting works into larger contexts, [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The concept of curating has arrived in the field of performing arts, and with it the understanding that programming performances, theatre works, dance pieces, or music can be more than just selecting or producing shows and then inserting them into a time slot and space. There is a necessity of putting works into larger contexts, to have them interact with each other and the world that informs them. And there is a possibility of creating a collective experience not only within the performance itself, but rather turning a programme, festival, event, or venue into a larger field of communication and communing.</p>
<p>Even though concepts of curating within the field of visual arts are clearly more elaborated than within the performing arts, the relation between them has always been more reciprocal than is often acknowledged. After all it is no coincidence that Harald Szeemann, in many ways the prototype of a contemporary curator, compared his work to that of a theatre director, and that art theorist Beatrice von Bismarck emphasises the propinquity of an exhibition-maker’s task to that of a dramaturg.</p>
<p>But taking Szeemann’s idea of staging exhibitions seriously takes us even further. It raises the question of how curation not only generally borrows (and often without any awareness) the tools of theatre, performance, and choreography but rather how it could gain even more from these practices by consciously integrating their very strategies and techniques, and by understanding curation itself as performative.</p>
<p><strong>Performing the Performative</strong></p>
<p>The impressive (and sometimes exaggerated) career of the concept of the performative began with J. L. Austin’s ‘speech acts’, introduced in his set of lectures ‘How to Do Things with Words’ (1955). As a precursor to the idea of performativity it described verbal utterances that exercise the transformative capacity of an act that constitutes or changes reality. The mainly linguistic discourse that followed Austin was, in the early 1990s, the base for Judith Butler’s radical interpretation of gender as something that is performed and constructed via speech or physical action: reality as a social construction coming to existence by permanently repeating and quoting. Performativity for Butler is, as described in <em>Bodies that Matter</em> (1993), ‘that reiterative power of discourse to produce the phenomena that it regulates and constrains.’</p>
<p>While definitions of performativity are numerous, often contradictory, and regularly rather vague, most are connected to a constructivist belief that there are no fixed concepts of objectivity, reality, or truth, and that everything is constructed individually, influenced by context and interaction.</p>
<p>Influential impulses in theatre and performance studies came next to the linguist arguments from ethnographical and anthropological discourses: the term ‘cultural performance’ was introduced in 1959 by ethnologist Milton Singer’s book <em>Traditional India: Structure and Change</em>. Singer believed that in many cultures performances, like dances, theatre, and rituals (defined by having a dramaturgy, a division between performer and audience, a framed time, a specific reason and place etc.) enable people to reassure themselves of their traditions and identities. Anthropologist Victor Turner continued to develop the concept of cultural performance, which was picked up by theatre makers and theorists like Richard Schechner, who collaborated with Turner, applied his discoveries to theatre, and pushed them further. As different as all these concepts of the performative are they all emphasise in one way or the other its ‘reality-making capacity’, as Shannon Jackson puts it in this book.</p>
<p>Yet there is another strand of the use of the word ‘performative’ — equally vague and additionally rather colloquial. It describes, again in Jackson’s words, art works that are ‘theatre-like but not theatre’, mainly to ‘provide an umbrella to cluster recent crossdisciplinary work in time, in space, with bodies, in relational encounters.’ Jackson calls this the ‘intermedial use of the performative vocabulary’ that often ‘foregrounds the sometimes productive, sometimes uncomfortable, relation between the performing arts and the visual arts.’</p>
<p>Keeping Szeemann in mind, it is this very notion of ‘theatrelike but not theatre’ that despite often being dismissed as too literal, opens up a whole range of possibilities when applied to the processes and products of curating: how can the understanding of dramaturgy, time management, narration, process, use of space, the co-presence of the audience, role play etc. — many of which were already important for Singer’s definition of ‘cultural performance’ — inform curatorial work?</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Putting the urinal back in the restroom. The symbolic and the direct power of art and activism</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/putting-the-urinal-back-in-the-restroom-the-symbolic-and-the-direct-power-of-art-and-activism/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 08 Dec 2022 13:52:53 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/putting-the-urinal-back-in-the-restroom-the-symbolic-and-the-direct-power-of-art-and-activism/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Art is not a mirror to hold up to reality, but a hammer with which to shape it. Attributed to Marx, Brecht, Mayakovsky… When mathematician and philosopher Antanas Mockus became mayor of Bogotá in 1995, the city was considered one of the most dangerous in the world, a community destroyed by drugs, crime, corruption, and [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><p><strong>Art is not a mirror to hold up to reality,<br />
but a hammer with which to shape it.</strong> Attributed to Marx, Brecht, Mayakovsky…</p></blockquote>
<p>When mathematician and philosopher Antanas Mockus became mayor of Bogotá in 1995, the city was considered one of the most dangerous in the world, a community destroyed by drugs, crime, corruption, and machismo. Mockus, not a professional politician at all, had run his campaign with no party support and virtually no budget but with the strong belief in the possibility of convincing people that a different world was possible. He believed that the most important thing to do as a mayor was to encourage people to trust themselves, to take their lives in their own hands and to strengthen their feeling of responsibility for the society they were part of. And he invented the concept of citizen culture, <em>cultura ciudadana</em>, as he describes in this book: a kind of civic selfeducation method based on play, symbolic actions, and staged situations.</p>
<p>But most significantly he claimed: “When I am trapped, I do what an artist would do.” Borrowing strategies from contemporary art meant for him decontextualizing everyday situations, framing them, making them graspable. And, at the same time, it meant a feeling of internal freedom, the ability to see things in their complexity from a distance, and thereby making change possible. He called his strategy subart: a modest art without symbolic pretentions, a way of borrowing from <em>high art</em> whatever could be useful and introduced into direct political action. His measures as mayor became world famous. He exchanged weapons for toys (counting on kids to put pressure on their parents), he publicly wore a “super citizen” costume to make fun of his own presumed power, as well as to illustrate that everybody in democracy has the ability to govern, that power should always be shared. He cut the form of a heart out of his bulletproof vest to demonstrate his commitment to nonviolence—and actually risked his life. He founded libraries in the most neglected parts of the city, running completely on trust, with no need to show ID to borrow a book. He organized performances at open graves to talk about violence and homicide, and he fired the corrupt traffic police and replaced them with more than 400 mimes in the belief that being ridiculed would be more of a deterrent for Columbians than any fine. And… he succeeded. Within three years water usage dropped forty percent, traffic fatalities over fifty percent, and the homicide rate fell seventy percent. 63,000 Bogotá citizens voluntarily agreed to pay ten percent higher taxes.</p>
<p>Mimes, cutout hearts, performances at open gravesides—all this might not exactly be considered good art by the standards of our esthetic discourses. But how often does art have such a direct impact?</p>
<p>Art and politics have always had an intense love-hate relationship. Artists positioned—or sometimes just found—themselves between servile obedience to the powers-that-be and critical distance, between constructive cooperation and outright antagonism. There is no way to place oneself outside the empire, even as an artist, hard as some might have tried. Even inner exile exists only in relation to the outer world.</p>
<p>But, despite repeated claims, this does not mean all art is political. Engaged art is more than mere relational reflection or esthetics. It takes a stand, or provokes others to take a stand. It does not only want change; it wants to be an active part of this change, or even to initiate it. It is not by chance that the artistic tools used in this struggle are often developed, or at least radicalized, at moments of social turmoil, at moments when the relationship between art and society is at a turning point in general: right before and after WWI (Dada, futurism, constructivism…), the 1960s, and the early 1970s (performance, concept, installation art…)—these were times of artistic and philosophical but also political avantgardes.</p>
<p>So it is not surprising that politically and socially engaged art gained fresh momentum after 1989, with the fall of the eastern bloc, the end of the cold war, the acceleration of capitalism and the corresponding rise of anti or alterglobalization movements. But only with the manifold political and economic crises all over the world in the last couple of years has the idea of activist art become more pointed and recently even a main topic even within the more mainstream contemporary art world. Whether in Tahrir, Zuccotti, Syntagma, Taksim, or Majdan Squares, in front of the Kremlin, in Japan after Fukushima, or in the midst of the iconic architecture of Brasilia, artists are always among the first to get involved. But one question constantly reoccurs: what role should art play in this?</p>
<p>It looks like we are witnessing another paradigm shift in the relationship of art and politics. A generation of philosophers who derived their theoretical concepts from their very own concrete political experiences and engagements (Michel Foucault fighting for human rights in prisons with the “Groupe d’information sur les prisons,” Alain Badiou being engaged in migration and asylum policies in the “Organization politique,” Jacques Rancière as a short term member in a Maoist group, Antonio Negri even sentenced to prison for his engagement in “Autonomia Organizzata,” to name but a few) was followed by new generations of philosophers (and artists, curators, etc.) who built on these thoughts and abstracted them further—but too often without binding them back to their own contemporary reality. So we got used to calling philosophical theories and art works “political,” even if they are only very distantly based on thoughts that themselves were already abstracted from the concrete political impulses that sparked them. A homeopathic, secondhand idea of political philosophy and art has become the main line of contemporary cultural discourse.</p>
<p>That classic leftist idea of the 1970s—“the personal is political”—was meant to politicize the private. But by now it seems rather to have privatized the political. The idea of “the esthetic is the political” was meant to politicize the esthetic. But it seems that over the years the political has been estheticized instead.</p>
<p>The constant awareness of the complexity of the notions of truth, reality, or even politics seem to have maneuvered us into a blind alley: either we are too simple or we are too complex, too populist or too stuck in hermetic eremitism. Either we include too much or we exclude too many. We have reached a point where the necessary awareness that everything is contingent has often become an excuse for intellectual relativism.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Blurring Boundaries/Changing Perspectives</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/blurring-boundaries-changing-perspectives/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 06 Dec 2022 21:36:10 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/blurring-boundaries-changing-perspectives/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Your work always builds on itself and develops further certain themes, motifs, and also aesthetic approaches. Mea Culpa has now become the third part of a trilogy about your illness with cancer. I have certainly produced work that was deliberately and purposefully developed to attract attention and nothing more. But sometimes that was a mistake [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Your work always builds on itself and develops further certain themes, motifs, and also aesthetic approaches. </em>Mea Culpa<em> has now become the third part of a trilogy about your illness with cancer.</em></p>
<p>I have certainly produced work that was deliberately and purposefully developed to attract attention and nothing more. But sometimes that was a mistake because doing that turned out to be completely uninteresting. The best things were those that developed unintentionally, where the work, for example, came into being as a result of an invitation out of the blue. That is even more clearly the case with the three pieces about cancer. They came out of nowhere &#8211; out of the shock that came with this illness. And, of course, it turned everything upside down. Suddenly all of my 350 kilometre-per-hour plans – my life at the time was super fast – were brought to a halt. But at the same time I didn’t see any reason to brake because cancer has to do with death and with the limitations of time that one has, but that wasn’t really clear to me at the time. It was actually a massive disruption. Like something that wants to prevent you from doing the work that is pulling at you. When I looked at the X-ray, I suddenly became very hot, as if I had made a huge mistake. The first thing I felt was a certain sense of guilt. In that moment, I probably already sensed: This is really such an insane rupture it is almost impossible to imagine. And then a flood of questions followed: What happens now? Operation? Radiotherapy? Chemotherapy? Will I still exist after the operation? And will I still have a voice afterwards? Because the doctor thought that he might have to remove my vocal nerves. And then you wake up and you can speak – that was really such a relief. Then my appetite returned and I came to terms with the whole situation, so I was optimistic. That is something that has remained with me. That is to say: I always have moments when I think: This is great, things go on. And then I fall to pieces again, you know: A complete nervous wreck, with absolutely no idea about how to cope with it, and I just think: It’s all over. And there is no way of driving a wedge between myself and it, or of flinging open a window.</p>
<p>It was thus pure expediency to say: good, if you have fear, then talk about fear. So the old automatism returned: If you have a problem, don’t think it away, deal with it. Then use it, grab it, and channel your sorrow into a comrade-in-arms. So I had to give form to it, create images, in order to cope with it and at first I thought: We will make a film as soon as I get out of hospital. A comedy about someone who has cancer and who only meets crazy people. Then I thought: That would just be the old sales and suppression strategy, ie. how do I give form to it in a way that people notice that I’m in control – and of course I’m not in control of it at all! It’s the complete opposite. It is probably the hardest experience of my life. In this case, I can stand neither above nor below it. This time I have definitely landed somewhere else. I am in it.</p>
<p><em>You made notes with the help of a dictaphone…</em></p>
<p>Yes, even in the first weeks, I recorded nearly every day what I experienced there and what happened when the doctor or the palliative nurse came etc. And in the evenings, I didn’t listen to it again. I did, however, cry and talk into the device, when nobody was there. It wasn’t a speech, or material, at that stage, for a book. It was simply a collection of everything that was racing through my head at the time. And then I had the idea of making a piece out of it – which I began to rehearse in the flat&#8230;from an automated bed with a remote control from the hospital. That was immediately a flop because, as a result of the Chemo, I wasn’t able to continue. Aino, my girlfriend at the time and now my wife, tried to reconstruct the material that I had worked on laboriously in the flat, on the rehearsal stage of the Maxim Gorki Theater. That resulted in the first performance of <em>Zwischenstand der Dinge</em> [<em>The Current State of Things</em>] which took place in a very intimate atmosphere with no press allowed. I made it while still in shock. Guests were invited solely via a text message &#8211; no other announcement was made. We had sixty or seventy seats for people including neighbours and friends, but also Bob Wilson and Volker Spengler, Werner Schroeter, who has cancer himself, Martin Wuttke…And because it was an evening without pressure and without a discussion afterwards, it was an incredible source of power for me: We pulled it off. Somehow it worked.</p>
<p>At that point I thought: Stick with this theme. And Zwischenstand was further developed into <em>Kirche der Angst</em> [<em>A Church of Fear for the Stranger in Me</em>] for the Ruhr-Triennale, as a sort of requiem or ‘cancer mass’. It was a huge success yet a different kind of success than previously. Something really happened between the audience and us &#8211; it was sincere and, to a certain extent, tragic. I also appeared in a short scene at the end of the performance that utilised the liturgy of a Catholic mass. But on the fifth or sixth evening, I thought: That’s enough. I don’t want to make touring theatre, or something, for people with cancer. That can’t be the case and it has no future. And then came the third part in the Burgtheater Vienna and, with it, the risk that people would perhaps think: Yeah, yeah, here he goes again about his illness…But then the situation changed again. The metastasen suddenly disappeared as a result of a tablet, something which, according to the doctors, wasn’t really possible in that period of time. After four or five weeks, I had a CT scan in which none could be found! How does that come about? The third part of the trilogy is concerned with life going on. What do you do, when you step back into reality, but you can’t perceive it as real because you previously thought you were already dead?</p>
<p>When someone dies, it is the loneliest path there is. It is not about hand-holding or whatever: My father smiled at the end. That was, however, a smile that I couldn’t understand. Was it, perhaps, the smile of someone face to face with a secret society that had taken him in? To see that was a heavy burden for me because he also told us that, in two weeks, he would be dead. And in two weeks he was dead. They are exceptional circumstances and we lack the criteria for working through them.</p>
<p><em>Can one actually grasp something like that in a production?</em></p>
<p>It can only function via music, and perhaps also via beliefs, ie. individual beliefs. One couldn’t go further with some sort of objective realism. Only through that which is ritualistic, almost sacred can one produce something that is befitting and moving. And the third part <em>Mea Culpa</em> was perhaps the most difficult: an uncertain resurrection, a celebration of life in the face of the inevitability of death.</p>
<p>In the middle of the stage, almost invisibly, I presided over the church, that is, the <em>Kirche der Angst</em>. Within it the ritual continues and someone there celebrates a requiem while outside are the treatment rooms and life follows its normal course… It is once again an argument [Auseinandersetzung] with the realisation that redemption is actually a concept that is completely misunderstood, and which one connects with something great and sublime. But redemption is the most individualistic, small, and awful step that there is. Because he who is done for, who seeks only to be redeemed gives himself over to total loneliness and surrenders everything that makes him who he is. That he is then told that everything will be fine and that he can cope – this is not really what is on his mind…If one has been through such a situation and come through it, one has more interest in people than before. One sees them differently. I look at them as if I were already standing a step outside of them. One looks at them perhaps not more exactly, not analytically, but longer. Humans and human life gain a different value. Everything is no longer taken for granted.</p>
<p>Sometimes of course, I slip into old mechanisms in my work, but they don’t really come through. It doesn’t become a show, because I don’t want that anymore. The distance is greater.<a href="applewebdata://DD0E9224-56F7-4B7F-8FC3-5DD5488290CB#_ednref1" name="_edn1"></a></p>
<p><em>Previously you were always on stage and committed to being involved. It was precisely this lack of distance that defined your work. From the earliest theatre productions on, you had to be able to join in, because otherwise you couldn’t respond to the reactions of the public and the actors’ routines. And now suddenly this composure?</em></p>
<p>Yes. I already had that with <em>Kirche der Angst</em>, when I simply pull back and my team reconstructs the work. And then I say, let’s put that in for now, and I lean back and look at it. Previously I didn’t permit such a situation. I didn’t want to see it. I didn’t want anything finished which is why I hesitated until the premiere. I was downright afraid that it would be finished. Now I mould the ‘sculpture’ more in my mind, and no longer believe that I have to work on it with an axe, hammer and a chisel. Now I can turn off more quickly. I am more interested in the total composition, which means that I need to be able to observe everything. And I also don’t fiddle around with the actors’ bodies as I used to and flip out in front of their faces, so that they no longer know how they should act. In the past, I always had muscular pain in the evening, because I actually wanted to play all of the roles. And now I just write the texts and concentrate more on looking. That is my job.</p>
<p><em>Your previous work was, in part, shaped by a notable paradox: you are, on the one hand, a complete control freak – you can’t leave the actors alone on the stage – and, on the other hand, you produce permanent chaos in order to limit or thwart your own control.  Has control become less important for you?</em></p>
<p>It could well be. It pleases me when things evolve more from themselves. I have less strength, but I think more. The whole time, I occupy myself with the texts, images and particularly the music. And at night I search for pieces of music, which is something I didn’t previously do. I try to respond when someone doesn’t understand something, whereas in the past, my immediate reaction was: Out! These days, someone will leave rather than me having to say he should no longer be there. But the control is greater, because I see it as an image, as a composition. I have to feel it first. Previously I almost had to catapult myself into a trance at each rehearsal.</p>
<p>The musicality that I have with opera is now more and more important. With theatre, one thinks a lot, und that is something that one can make great use of, but the structure is easily lost. The opera has more stability and provides a framework which is organic and not compulsive. A singer has to accept that he sings, he can’t just jump around. And for that reason, we don’t do a lot of theatrics with them, they should simply sing. I don’t believe them anyway when they start to introduce their pretence of naturalism.</p>
<p><em>So more the image of the whole – there is still control, but less getting tangled up in the details, in order to see the larger arc…</em></p>
<p>&#8230; and to also accept that this is simply how it is now. And not, as in the past, change something in the last few weeks and cut the text, so that the whole production dies in the process. I don’t do that anymore, because I really fight hard for the subject matter. And even if the text is, at first, a jumble of words, the music clarifies what is happening.  I now think in a very musical way. When you are lying in bed, there are not a lot of alternatives … I thought a lot while I was in bed, spoke a lot, read a lot but also listened to a lot of music. In terms of your question about rhythm, it is also interesting when you are simply lying there with an embolism. You simply do not have any chance of producing rhythm.</p>
<p><em>Is the work then more disembodied? Less physical?</em></p>
<p>Yes, I believe so. … In the past we pulled viewers onto the stage, bound them, and then smeared them with Nivea cream; a latent form of rape or something. It was, in any case, so corporeal that people went out and cried, because they couldn’t handle the violence that had befallen them during their visit to the theatre. We found that pretty great and exciting. Although at times we also had a bad conscience. That I hurt people because I pulled them onto the stage was, perhaps, justifiable at the time, but, at the moment, I have no connection to it, even a certain sense of disgust. Because that type of act makes the arrogant claim that: We are the ones who see through everything and will show you that we are breaking the rules and acknowledge no taboos. This attitude has become rather alien to me now. One can also employ theatre as a place where one can think. Back then, however, I couldn’t do that, because I felt virtually compelled to get into fights on the stage. We only enjoyed it when there was a ruckus. I don’t want to say that that was completely wrong – there were indeed great nights. Often, there were metaphysical moments as well. But people change.</p>
<p><em>The explicitly and concretely political work that emerged in this period – </em>Kühnen 94,<em> the party </em>Chance 2000<em>, the Vienna Container-Project </em>Please love Austria<em>, the </em>Hamlet <em>production with the Neo-Nazis in Zürich: How did these projects develop? Your work in film had often sought to draw mythical, historical connections… </em></p>
<p>At the age of eight – 1968 – I made a super-8 film with my father’s camera, where a farmer had to wave flags and three children in go-carts knocked him down and ran away. There was also a shootout or something similar. I don’t want to say that that was political, but something is captured in that image. During my school years, I would always have rows with the teachers because, for me they were too political, one-sidedly political. I once started a row with a teacher and had to leave the classroom, because I said that she only approached things from a left perspective, and that was too boring for me. The Oberhausen Short Film Festival also didn’t give me much pleasure because to my mind it was only pseudo political. People were invited from the eastern block to show their boring films. And then our worst filmmakers would show their films in Leipzig or somewhere else.</p>
<p>My father always received telegrams from the CDU [Christian Democratic Union] camp. I partly learned their contents by heart so that I – as a sixteen year old at the SPD [Social Democratic Party] voting stands – could use it in an argument against them. Simply as verbal fireworks. I did, however, always read those telegrams. And in Oberhausen, where very little information circulated, I also played around with statistics that they couldn’t rebut. Or I worked together with the KPD-ML [The Communist Party of Germany/Marxists-Leninists] because they claimed that an egg should only cost two or three pfennigs. At first I thought it was a great idea until I realised: the chicken doesn’t get anything out of it. So it was quite clear that I hadn’t really become political at all – it was rather something like an overarching need for recognition.</p>
<p>Later as a student in Munich, I began to develop a sense of antipathy toward the Film Academy. At that time I became interested in the films of Werner Herzog, because they were so detached. They were so strange. E<em>ven Dwarfs Started Small</em> was the kind of film I liked. I found it political. In contrast, I found these explicitly political films by Reinhard Hauff, Margarethe von Trotta and others to be no good at all. I also felt, in part, extremely aggressive towards Wenders: reproducing stupid crap from America, but so badly. But I liked <em>The American Friend</em>, and I thought <em>Alice in the Cities </em>and <em>The State of Things</em> were great. I liked, in a sense, their avowal that someone had failed. That one can’t leave the city. Or that one has cancer and wants to rescue the family.</p>
<p>I actually felt at home with Werner Nekes for whom I worked as an assistant, and I gathered ammunition from experimental films that could be used against mainstream cinema. ie. Stan Brakhage and Andy Warhol. For me, that was political enough. My work only became politically explicit with <em>Menu Total</em> – that was in 1986. In this film, Helge Schneider &#8211; who was unknown back then – ran around playing a young boy who wanted to become Hitler, and who wiped out his family. And later they all rise again and are redeemed….</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“We need a new social Imaginary”</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/we-need-a-new-social-imaginary-a-conversation-with-chantal-mouffe/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Florian Malzacher]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 28 Nov 2022 11:13:47 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/we-need-a-new-social-imaginary-a-conversation-with-chantal-mouffe/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[You have often emphasised your belief that only a left populism could stop the rise of the right-wing. You propose a political strategy that does not shy away from passionate campaigns, from clear statements, from direct confrontation. And there seems to have been a clear momentum for such a development – with Syriza in Greece, [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>You have often emphasised your belief that only a left populism could stop the rise of the right-wing. You propose a political strategy that does not shy away from passionate campaigns, from clear statements, from direct confrontation. And there seems to have been a clear momentum for such a development – with Syriza in Greece, Podemos in Spain, with Jeremy Corbyn in the UK and Bernie Sanders in the US and many more. But today we rather witness a conservative or even authoritarian turn. Is left populism for progressive movements and parties still the path to follow? </strong></p>
<p>I strongly disagree with the view that the time for leftist populism is over and that now it is time to return to traditional left politics, meaning: class politics. When you look at Podemos in Spain for example: people are complaining that the movement did not achieve what was hoped for. But expectations were just too high, the hope that everything would change immediately. That is a wrong understanding of left populism. Left populism is not to be envisaged in terms of what Antonio Gramsci called a “war of manoeuvre”, a fast insurrection, but instead in terms of a “war of position”, a complex struggle that needs time. We should not imagine a movement that emerges and then straight comes to power. It is a process, a hegemonic struggle. What is at stake is the construction of a new hegemony. The argument that the momentum for left populism has passed is therefore based on a wrong understanding of this strategy. It is always going to be a process, a war of position in which there will be moments of advance and moments of retreats.<br />
We see that clearly in Latin America. After the ‘pink tide’ there was quite a setback – but now we see the return of national populist movements to power in several countries. For Europe, we will see… Obviously Corbyn did not win the election, but the struggle continues. Let’s see what happens in France with Jean-Luc Mélenchon – I am not very optimistic that he will win next year, but it is not completely impossible. And even if he doesn’t win – that does not mean that left populism is finished. I am convinced this is the only strategy for the left to win, the only type of politics that corresponds with the current situation. I don’t see any other way. Certainly not returning to traditional politics. And the pandemic shows this even more clearly.</p>
<p><strong>How do you define left populism?</strong></p>
<p>It is a political strategy in which we can basically distinguish three main features: First of all, it requires defining an adversary, drawing a political frontier – a frontier between those ‘from below’ and ‘those from above’. You might argue that this is what traditional Marxists always have been saying. And yes, with this point I agree. But for a traditional Marxist this frontier is between the working class and the capitalist class. In the times we are living in, we can’t just limit the project of the left to the interests of the workers. Their interests are important and socialist parties have for too long abandoned the working class. But in our societies, there are also many other important issues like ecology, feminism, anti-racism and LGBT+ demands.<br />
So that is the second feature: a leftist populist strategy aims at the construction of a ‘people’, a transversal collective will in which many different democratic demands, coming from a variety of sectors are taken into account. The demands of the working class have to be articulated with the demands of other social movements. So you need to construct a ‘people’ that is an articulation of what Ernesto Laclau and I in Hegemony and Socialist Strategy called “a chain of equivalence” between several democratic demands. This is a clear difference to the traditional Marxist strategy.<br />
The third important feature is that in the construction of this collective will it is vital to take account of the affective dimension, the part of common affects that I call ‘passions’. This collective will is not going to be created solely on the basis of arguments and a good program. We need to acknowledge the crucial role played by passions – I cannot repeat that often enough. The left is much too rationalistic</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Almost Like a Teaching Play</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/almost-like-a-teaching-play-daniel-wetzel-rimini-protokoll-in-a-conversation-with-florian-malzacher/</link>
					<comments>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/almost-like-a-teaching-play-daniel-wetzel-rimini-protokoll-in-a-conversation-with-florian-malzacher/#respond</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[hff]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 11 Aug 2022 15:42:29 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/almost-like-a-teaching-play-daniel-wetzel-rimini-protokoll-in-a-conversation-with-florian-malzacher/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/almost-like-a-teaching-play-daniel-wetzel-rimini-protokoll-in-a-conversation-with-florian-malzacher/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Bethinking One’s Own Strengths. The Performative Potential of Curating</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/bethinking-ones-own-strengths-the-performative-potential-of-curating/</link>
					<comments>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/bethinking-ones-own-strengths-the-performative-potential-of-curating/#respond</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[hff]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 10 Aug 2022 14:38:52 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/bethinking-ones-own-strengths-the-performative-potential-of-curating/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Maybe it is symptomatic of the strange untimeliness of theater that it has introduced the concept of the curator to the field of live arts at what seems to be a rather badly chosen moment: for even though curation remains a buzzword in the visual arts where it has experienced an unprecedented boom over the [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Maybe it is symptomatic of the strange untimeliness of theater that it has introduced the concept of the curator to the field of live arts at what seems to be a rather badly chosen moment: for even though curation remains a buzzword in the visual arts where it has experienced an unprecedented boom over the last decades, it is also increasingly criticized. Does the curator aim to be a meta-artist, ultimately creating art without artists? Is the curator a neo-liberal agent, fulfilling the market demands even before the market itself demands them, well wrapped in seemingly anti-capitalist discourse? And is it not anyway a diluted, empty term by now, when every shop window is subject to curating?</p>
<p>So it does not come as a surprise that now, as the concept of curating slowly makes its way into the world of the live arts, it is confronted with quite a bit of skepticism. After all, theater tends to consider itself one of the last places of resistance against the imposition of the very neoliberalism that the visual arts, with their especially close relationship to market economy, is so much part of. And is not the title of a curator already actually just a sales device, used in the desire to snatch some of the glamour of the shiny world of galleries and biennales, appropriated by theater and festival programmers, producers, and dramaturges for its sexier sound rather than as a token for a real commitment to changing one&#8217;s own practice?</p>
<p>Resentment meets some good arguments in these debates, which are often conducted as a superficial substitute for other discussions. This has most prominently been seen in the recent heated exchanges around former Tate Modern director and visual arts curator Chris Deron taking over the legendary Berlin theater Volksbühne after the exit of the ground-breaking Frank Castorf. The debates rage over theater versus visual arts, repertoire/ ensemble theater versus international production house, drama versus post-drama, local versus global, ethos versus post-politics, sustainability versus event, social democracy versus market, and so on. The figure of the curator is a stand-in for many of these battlefields and became a symbol for the changes and challenges that confront mainly ensemble-based and text-based repertory theaters. But a deeper consideration of what curating in the live arts can actually contribute to artistic, aesthetic, political, discursive thinking is symptomatically not part of this debate.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/bethinking-ones-own-strengths-the-performative-potential-of-curating/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Discomforts, Obstacles and Artistic Infidelities. The Theatre of Kelly Copper and Pavol Liška</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/discomforts-obstacles-and-artistic-infidelities-the-theatre-of-kelly-copper-and-pavol-liska/</link>
					<comments>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/discomforts-obstacles-and-artistic-infidelities-the-theatre-of-kelly-copper-and-pavol-liska/#respond</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[hff]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 10 Aug 2022 13:55:33 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/discomforts-obstacles-and-artistic-infidelities-the-theatre-of-kelly-copper-and-pavol-liska/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[The great Theatre of Oklahoma calls you! Today only and never again! If you miss your chance now you miss it for ever! If you think of your future, you are one of us! Everyone is welcome. If you want to be an artist, join our company! Our theatre can ﬁnd employment for everyone, a [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><p><strong>The great Theatre of Oklahoma calls you! Today only and never again! If you miss your chance now you miss it for ever! If you think of your future, you are one of us! Everyone is welcome. If you want to be an artist, join our company! Our theatre can ﬁnd employment for everyone, a place for everyone!</strong> Franz Kafka, <em>Amerika</em></p></blockquote>
<p>Only today, for one time only! The Great Theatre of Oklahoma! Kelly Copper and Pavol Liška had been keeping the name of the immoderately ambitious touring troupe from Kafka’s <em>Amerika</em> in mind for a long time – for the day they would found their own company. Not only because the unﬁnished novel had served Liška as a kind of instruction manual to his new homeland after emigrating from Slovakia (the same part of the world that both Kafka and <em>Amerika</em>’s protagonist Karl Roßmann are from), but also the grandiose gesture of the poster and the mind-boggling dimensions of the dubious-sounding Nature Theatre of Oklahoma held a powerful attraction for the two unknown theatre-makers who, with a combination of modesty and strength of will, had no doubts that they had something substantial to offer as artists.</p>
<p>In 1991, at the age of 18, an obscure job offer suddenly gave Liška, who had grown up in a small town in Slovakia, the opportunity to move to the USA. He had never been abroad before, spoke no English, and was actually supposed to join the Army – but instead, a few weeks later, he ended up in Oklahoma. He learned the language at night (when he wasn’t working) to be able to follow his classes in Philosophy and Writing at college during the day, constantly afraid of losing his student visa if his grades weren’t good enough. After a year in a rather desperate work and life situation in Oklahoma he transferred to Dartmouth College in New Hampshire, where he met Kelly Copper in a seminar on Dadaist performance (a remarkably unpopular course with only three students in attendance) and the two became an inseparable pair. Copper graduated in 1993 and moved to New York.</p>
<p>While Liška was visiting her over Christmas that year they had seen <em>Frank Dell’s the Temptation of St. Antony </em>by The Wooster Group, Reza Abdoh’s <em>Quotations from a Ruined City</em> and Richard Foreman’s <em>My Head was a Sledgehammer</em> – in a kind of crash course one after another – and their entire concept of theatre was turned upside down. Liška, who was busy directing one of his own plays at college, came back and immediately told his fellow students: “that we have been doing it all wrong, and have to change everything. These three shows I saw in New York really made me realize what theatre could be.”</p>
<p>Since then Kelly Copper and Pavol Liška, who have called themselves Nature Theater of Oklahoma since 2004, have themselves created some of the most remarkable theatre works to be seen in the former capital of the avant-garde in recent years: unmistakable in their combination of conceptual rigour, an idiosyncratic mix of modernist art strategies (at times closer to the visual than the performing arts) and exultantly theatrical performance that refuses to shy away from apparently trashy surfaces while uninhibitedly poaching from all manner of theatrical traditions.</p>
<p>Even if their greatest success has come in Europe, their theatre remains unmistakeably North American – not least because in their works they draw on typically Anglo-American genres such as dinner theatre (in <em>No Dice</em>), musicals (<em>Life and Times – Episode 1</em>), show choirs (<em>Episode 2</em>), vaudeville mystery theatre (<em>Episodes 3 &amp; 4</em>), Western movies (<em>Pursuit of Happiness</em>), Hollywood classics like <em>Citizen Kane</em> (<em>Episode 7</em>), North American landscape painting (<em>Episode 8</em>) and gangsta rap (<em>Episode 9</em>).</p>
<p>Most of all, however, they have been inﬂuenced by their home city of New York. Most of Nature Theater’s idols live or did live in Manhattan: Marcel Duchamp the inventor of the readymade; Andy Warhol, who turned the everyday into art; John Cage and Merce Cunningham, who made chance a protagonist; Ken Jacobs and Joseph Cornell and their ﬁlmic compositions of found materials; The Wooster Group with its fascination with technical perfection and information overload; and not least the unique Jack Smith, who celebrated trash and camp as original aesthetics – all of them have inﬂuenced Nature Theater, that consciously and enthusiastically roots itself in these traditions.</p>
<p>Among theatremakers it is ﬁrst and foremost Richard Foreman and his handling of props and the audience that has left the most evident traces. Pavol Liška joined the legendary director’s team in the mid-1990s and helped on several productions: “It was the most formative experience for me, and sometimes I feel like I learned everything I know about directing from Richard Foreman.” Foreman was also the one who gave them the chance to show their ﬁrst work in New York at his theatre in 1996. “Our ﬁrst 3 or 4 shows in New York were an attempt to imitate him.” And even later, long after they had found their own highly individual artistic path, Foreman remained a mentor and role model: “I learned from him to shape every small unit of time, to be rigorous, and never make compromises. His shows were built like sculptures out of words, gestures, movements, props, scenery. He built perfectly constructed worlds, and we struggled to do the same. Richard Foreman is never too far away from my mind when I direct.”</p>
<p>Now the couple live in Long Island City, Queens – Manhattan with its famous skyline is now more distant but remains in view (at least for the moment) until the crush of constantly expanding skyscrapers will hide it ﬁnally from sight.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/discomforts-obstacles-and-artistic-infidelities-the-theatre-of-kelly-copper-and-pavol-liska/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Lola Arias: Identities in Negotiation</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/lola-arias-identities-in-negotiation/</link>
					<comments>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/lola-arias-identities-in-negotiation/#respond</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[hff]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 04 Aug 2022 16:42:42 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/lola-arias-identities-in-negotiation/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/lola-arias-identities-in-negotiation/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Theatre as Assembly. Spheres of Radical Imagination and Pragmatic Utopias</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/theatre-as-assembly/</link>
					<comments>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/theatre-as-assembly/#respond</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[tillbortels]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 15 Jul 2022 16:49:07 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/theatre-as-assembly/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/theatre-as-assembly/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Theatre as Assembly</title>
		<link>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/theatre-as-assembly-short/</link>
					<comments>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/theatre-as-assembly-short/#respond</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[tillbortels]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 24 Jun 2022 17:38:14 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://florianmalzacher.net/content/theatre-as-assembly-short/</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[“Close all theatres for one year, and then let’s see what we really need them for”: no wonder Heiner Müller’s provocation was trending during the time of Covid-19 lockdowns when venues and festivals were shut down – not for a full year, but at least for some weeks and months. But instead of fundamentally rethinking [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Close all theatres for one year, and then let’s see what we really need them for”: no wonder Heiner Müller’s provocation was trending during the time of Covid-19 lockdowns when venues and festivals were shut down – not for a full year, but at least for some weeks and months. But instead of fundamentally rethinking the own medium and its routines, there was a constant activity. Streamings and discussions, readings, lectures, Zoom-performances… Theatres were closed almost worldwide and there was more theatre available every day than anyone could possibly watch. The horror vacui was too strong. It prevented almost any silence, almost any taking time to re-evaluate our arts and our lives. As if we were afraid, the moment we’d stop, all would fall apart forever.</p>
<p>But within this never-ending talking and doing there was actually a hidden answer to Heiner Müller. While the phantom pain was growing, it became more and more apparent that all the screening and Zooming was not even close to the real thing. It was a permanent referring to something absent. To something that used to be there and hopefully would be there again soon. It only existed in this relationship.</p>
<p>If we stripped away everything that isn’t essential to theatre, what would be left? More than any other art form, theatre is a medium of assembly. A place to come together, to invent, try out, discuss. A medium of physical presence, an agonistic arena in which society can negotiate their conﬂicts and foster radical imagination.</p>
<p>Like activists’ assemblies, it marks a zone of gathering, of building community, of making decisions – and thus a zone of experimenting with the way democracy can function. A physical space, a space of bodies, like Judith Butler points out in her speech at Occupy Wall Street:</p>
<blockquote><p><strong>It matters that as bodies we arrive together in public. As bodies we suffer, we require food and shelter, and as bodies we require one another in dependency and desire. So this is a politics of the public body, the requirements of the body, its movement and its voice. […] We sit and stand and move as the popular will, the one that electoral politics has forgotten and abandoned. But we are here, time and again, persisting, imagining the phrase, ‘we the people’.</strong></p></blockquote>
<p>But still there is a crucial difference: the activist/anarchist assembly is generally considered a space of authentic negotiation, a space for trying to abolish established hierarchies, for not only trying out but living a different way of decision-making, usually based on the concept of consensus. While theatre as assembly might sympathise strongly with these ideas, I would argue that at the end it has an essentially different take. Theatre is not only a social but also always a self-reﬂexive practice, despite the fact that conventional approaches have been neglecting this. Theatre is a paradoxical machine that marks a sphere where things are real and not real at the same time and proposes situations and practices that are symbolic and actual at once. It does not enable an artiﬁcial outside of pure criticality, nor is it able to lure its audience into mere immersive identiﬁcation. The social spheres, the assemblies it can create offer the possibility of partaking and at the same time watching oneself from the outside. Brecht’s alienation effect is not an invention; it is a discovery of what constitutes all theatre. It’s just that not all theatre admits it – or even tries to make consistent use of it.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://florianmalzacher.de/content/theatre-as-assembly-short/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
	</channel>
</rss>
